Showing posts with label Justice Samuel Alito. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Justice Samuel Alito. Show all posts

Monday, March 26, 2012

Justice Actually Can Prevail

The monster that is the Environmental Protection Agency has just received a big slapdown from the United States Supreme Court. The EPA, using its huge resources, entrenched bureaucratic mentality, seemingly endless ability to spend the taxpayers money and determination that it is a law unto itself lost a true David versus Goliath battle. A family which refused to be intimidated by Leviathan won.

I’ve written on this topic twice before, each time with the hope that this brave couple, Mike and Chantell Sackett would be able to fight on until they won their battle to re-establish the very American proposition that your land belongs to you, not to the federal government and a gaggle of environmental fascists. You can review the underlying facts of the case here: Sacketts vs EPA. So this post is actually more celebratory than the previous two.

In a nutshell, the case involves a small parcel of land which the Sacketts had purchased so they could build their dream home in the Priest Lake region of Idaho. After pulling all the proper permits and complying with all environmental regulations imposed by the local, regional and state authorities, the Sacketts began to build. After the Sacketts had graded the land, laid the foundation for the house and erected some of the walls and support structures, the EPA came in, ordered the construction to halt forthwith, and ordered the Sacketts to dismantle what construction had been done and return the land to its natural state as a protected wetland.

The idea that the land was a protected wetland came as a total surprise to the Sacketts and every agency involved except the EPA. The “wetland” amounted to a small portion of the property, not much more than a puddle, which had only come to exist as the result of an unusually wet winter and spring. It hadn’t been there before or during the permit process, and left alone, would dry up on its own eventually. No wetland flora or fauna had yet discovered the puddle. It takes the sharp eye of an EPA bureaucrat to locate such obscure ecological marvels.

This was another example of ecoweenies and federal bureaucrats finding a “problem” to act on in order to make sure that their power intimidates both the objects of the protection orders and anyone else who might dare to think of building on or near the same location. Why is it suddenly a protected wetland? The EPA’s response was “because we say it is.”

What was determined in the Supreme Court decision is that the EPA (and by inference, other federal alphabet agencies) may not prevent injured plaintiffs from challenging the power of the agency early in the proceedings. In order to win by intimidation, the EPA had issued what is called a “compliance order.” Such an order requires that the victims of that order must first comply with all the terms of the order before attaining standing to sue the agency for a reversal of the order. For a family of moderate means, that is a near impossibility.

The Sacketts would have had to pull down all the construction done so far, including re-grading the land to put it back into its “natural state.” Then, and only then, they would have been allowed to challenge the EPA’s determination that their land was a protected wetland. Assuming they won the subsequent suit (no sure thing), they would then be able to start construction all over.

As an additional bullet in the head of the Sackett’s dreams, refusal to obey the compliance order would mean they could spend their limited funds on reversing the construction, then hiring counsel to sue just to get back where they started or pay daily fines of $37,500 until they did comply. The Sacketts chose not to comply, and after unsuccessful appeals, their fines had reached nearly $1 million by the time the case got to the Supreme Court.

The argument in court revolved around the nature of the compliance order, with the issue of the questionable wetlands determination a secondary issue. The EPA contended that a compliance order is only one step in ongoing litigation to make that determination. The Sacketts argued the opposite. And the high court agreed with the Sacketts. Speaking for the unanimous court, Justice Antonin Scalia wrote that the Sacketts had the right to sue to overturn the compliance order rather than obey it at their own expense and litigate further later.

Scalia reviewed the Administrative Procedures Act on which the EPA relied, and found that a compliance order such as the one in this case is so onerous that it comprises a final order, complete with monetary fines. The order requiring the Sacketts to restore the property to its original condition was therefore subject to immediate judicial review, both under the Administrative Procedures Act and the Clean Water Act.

No need for a private citizen to bankrupt himself complying with the order before suing to overturn the agency decision only to get back to where he was in the first place before the arbitrary and crippling order was entered. Scalia added: “There is no reason to think that the Clean Water Act was uniquely designed to enable the strong-arming of regulated parties into ‘voluntary compliance’ without the opportunity for judicial review—even judicial review of the question whether the regulated party is within the EPA’s jurisdiction.”

Justice Samuel Alito also suggested that Congress amend the Clean Water Act, the Administrative Procedures Act, and similar bureaucratic legislation in a way that would clearly and affirmatively define the limitations of compliance orders while at the same time preventing more arbitrary and capricious actions by federal agencies effectively quashing the right of private citizens to seek redress in the courts at the earliest possible time. Said Alito: “The Court’s opinion is better than nothing, but only clarification of the reach of the Clean Water Act can rectify the underlying problem.”

The attorney for the Sacketts argued before the Justices that the EPA (and by inference, any other federal agency) is not above the law, nor does any such agency have the right to prevent private citizens from seeking legal redress against the agency when those citizens reasonably believe they are being treated unfairly. He further argued that private citizens should not be required to suffer crippling sanctions without being able to petition the courts to grant redress and protect private property rights pending further litigation. The Supreme Court unanimously agreed.

Although this was an important and unanimous decision, caution must be advised before determining that this battle won a war. The EPA doesn’t like being told it has limited powers, and under this administration at least, it’s likely that it ain’t over ‘til it’s over. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote a concurring opinion which pointed out that the underlying issue of whether the Sackett’s property is or is not a protected wetland is not being determined by this Supreme Court decision.

The decision is limited to the right of a private citizen to challenge a compliance order without first having to comply with it. In other words, big government-friendly Ginsburg wanted the EPA to know that she, Justice Sotomayor and perhaps one other Justice might very well be amenable to accepting their determination that the Sackett’s property is in fact a protected wetland if the case should make its way back to the Supreme Court on that issue alone.

I’ll take my victories where I can find them. This was a major limitation placed on the power of irresponsible poorly-monitored federal agencies to harass, intimidate and threaten private citizens into surrendering to unjust federal authority. In order to win the final battle and ultimately the war, Congress must act to severely restrict the now nearly-unlimited powers of the EPA to declare private property off-limits to the citizens who own it. Now you have another reason to elect a conservative Republican majority to Congress in the upcoming general election, as well as kicking The One out of the White House.
[+] Read More...

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Through The Legal Looking Glass--The Nine Gray Eminences

Associate Justice Samuel Anthony Alito was born on April 1 (no jokes, please), 1950 in Trenton New Jersey. Shortly thereafter, his family moved to nearby Hamilton Township. He comes from a middle class Italian-American family. His father was a high school teacher who later moved on to become the first Director of the New Jersey Office of Legislative Services. His mother retired as a school teacher.

He graduated from Steinert High School in Hamilton, and went on to nearby Princeton University, obtaining a bachelor of arts degree in public and international affairs from the university's Woodrow Wilson School. He is Roman Catholic. While at Princeton, he became active in school affairs. In 1971, he led a student conference called The Boundaries of Privacy in American Society. He was conservative in most political matters, but definitely exhibited some strong libertarian tendencies. The conference concluded that domestic intelligence-gathering should be more carefully scrutinized, called for the decriminalization of sodomy, and came down heavily on the side of eliminating discrimination in hiring for gays.

He also was sufficiently low on the draft lottery numbers that he decided to sign up for the Army ROTC program. After graduating from Princeton, he joined with the Concerned Alumni of Princeton in expressing opposition to the Yale administration's promotion of affirmative action as well as its attempts to remove the ROTC program from the school's premises. He never became a formal member of the group, which later was accused of moving beyond affirmative action and drifting into anti-black rhetoric. Alito said publicly that his early agreement was based on his opposition to the Yale policy, but that he abhorred racism in any form. During his senior year, he completed his Princeton degree studying in Italy, where he wrote his thesis on the Italian legal system. He became so enamored of the law, and how American jurisprudence differed from almost any other system, that he decided to go on to law school.

He attended Yale Law School, and served as the editor of the Yale Law Journal, earning his J.D. in 1975. Before starting law school, he was commissioned as a Second Lieutenant in the Army Signal Corps, and served active duty in 1975 while getting his training at Fort Gordon, Georgia. Thereafter, he served in the inactive Reserves, where he rose to the rank of captain before receiving his honorable discharge in 1980.

Upon graduation from Yale Law, Alito clerked for a judge on the Third Circuit Court of Appeals. He had applied for the opening in Supreme Court Justice Byron White's office, but White was a big football fan, and former player, and Alito was not. That appointment fell through. After his clerkship, he served as an Assistant U. S. Attorney for New Jersey, and specialized in prosecuting cases involving drug trafficking and organized crime. He became the resident expert on RICO (the Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act). Moving over to the civil side, he served from 1981 to 1985 as Assistant U. S. Solicitor General.

He then became a Deputy Assistant to Attorney General Edwin Meese. He started demonstrating his judicial philosophy on his application for that job. He supported conservative views, and cited William F. Buckley, Alexander Bickel and Barry Goldwater as major influences. He also expressed strong reservations about the Warren Court's activism and disregard for precedent, particularly in First Amendment cases relating to the Establishment Clause. This led to his nomination by the first President Bush to be a judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. He was rated well-qualified by the American Bar Association, which blunted some of the attacks on him coming from the liberal side which had earlier done such damage to Judge Bork's nomination to the Supreme Court.

In 1985, Alito married Martha-Ann Bomgardner, a law librarian who met Alito during one of his many trips to the law library while he was a clerk. They have two children, Philip and Laura. Until his Supreme Court appointment, the family resided in West Caldwell, New Jersey. He took a position as an adjunct professor at Seton Hall University School of Law, and remained there from 1994 to 2004. He taught constitutional law and an honors class in civil liberties and terrorism. He is a long-time member of the Federalist Society, a group of conservative/libertarian lawyers and legal professionals.

Associate Justice Sandra Day O'Connor announced her intention to resign in 2005, as soon as the President decided on a replacement. The second President Bush first nominated John Roberts to the vacancy. However, before the formal vetting process had gained much ground, Chief Justice William Rehnquist died, and Bush withdrew the nomination, intending to name Roberts to the position of Chief Justice. Bush then made a major mistake in appointing a Bush insider, Harriet Miers to the position instead of Alito. The conservatives and federalists in the Republican Party came unglued, and savaged Miers over her cronyism and Washington cocktail circuit credentials. Miers withdrew from the nomination on October 27, 2005. On October 31, Bush then nominated Alito, having successfully gotten Roberts into the Chief Justice position earlier.

The liberal-left came out against the nomination in full attack mode. The ACLU formally opposed his nomination, only the third time it had done so. The last open opposition was their rabid attack on Judge Bork. Completely ignoring all of Alito's work both as a teacher and as an appellate judge in regard to civil liberties in times of national emergencies, the ACLU honed in on Alito's conservatism as indicating that "Our President has claimed unprecedented authority to spy on Americans and jail terrorism suspects indefinitely . . . and America needs a Supreme Court Justice who will uphold our precious civil liberties." The left was determined to exercise every effort to undermine the Iraq war, so it distorted the truth about the President's actions, and completely misstated or misunderstood Alito's very cautious views on the dangers to civil liberties in wartime. But licking its wounds from past attacks for its partisanship, the American Bar Association again rated Alito well-qualified.

Botoxed sleepwalker and reporting-for-duty failed Presidential candidate John Kerry, exercising his usual organizational skills and great charisma, attempted to put a filibuster of the nomination together. As with pretty much everything else he has ever done (except marrying the pickle princess and getting re-elected in Massachusetts), he failed. Ted Kennedy tried to paint Alito as another Bork, trying to force women to have their abortions in back alleys and sending troops into people's homes to drag them off to prison camps in the middle of the night. In the end, Alito was confirmed by a vote of 58 to 42 in the Senate, second only in sitting justices to Justice Thomas for narrow victories (Thomas received a 52 to 48 vote as a result of the Anita Hill ambush).

Justice Alito is a very learned and deliberative judge. For those who do not follow decisions closely, and rely on summaries in the newspapers, I assure you that he is a conservative protector of the Constitution who has no hesitation at making it clear that when he disagrees with the other conservatives on the court, he does so both on strong constitutional ground and to protect individual liberties. However, those disagreements are rare. For that reason, some people have thought of Alito as being weak on abortion. He is not. In the case of the federal partial-birth abortion statute before the court, he voted with the majority to sustain the Congressional action, but indicated his reluctance for the issue to become the rule for the states. Because he disagreed with the majority contention directly addressing Roe v. Wade, he wrote a concurring opinion with Justice Scalia stating that the reversal of Roe v. Wade was not the issue in the case, and therefore had to wait for a proper case to come before the court. He was voting for the precedent represented by the case before the court, and not voting either for against Roe. Alito has indicated a willingness to overturn Roe in a proper case at the proper time with the proper pleadings. That is a very conservative judicial point of view.

As for free speech, again Alito seems liberal, but he is not. He upholds precedent on solid traditional grounds. He sees the First Amendment as being limited only by extreme circumstances, and never in advance. He voted with Roberts' majority opinion in Morse v. Frederick that speech in public secondary schools which promoted drug use can be properly banned both on the grounds of the power of the school to act in loco parentis, and the exigency of dangerous drug use among youngsters being promoted in a public institution. But he also stated his view that the moment the discussion became political, it was protected speech and could not be banned. Thus, at least in a public school below college level, saying "use drugs" can be forbidden. But arguing that medical marijuana should be legalized cannot.

In order to see that his views are conservative and traditional, but cautiously worded and predictable, it should be noted that he has voted with the conservative majority 87% of the time, but has joined in conservative majority opinions less than 75% of the time. For those unfamiliar with the way Supreme Court decisions are calculated, the final vote determines the outcome. But a justice voting with the majority can simply join, without any further expansion on his personal views of the law of the case. He can concur in part and dissent in part, thus standing with the majority on the result, but arguing that portions of the decision don't address important issues properly. Or he can write an entirely separate concurrence, essentially saying he agrees with the result the majority has reached, but not the reasoning the majority used to reach that result.

Alito has been consistent and predictable. He will continue to stand by the Constitution, read it in its strictest terms, and overturn precedent only when the specifics of the case call for it. He seems to be looking for the opportunity to overturn Roe v. Wade, but will not detour into the dangerous territory of ruling on issues that are not before the court. If and when the opportunity presents itself, and should the long-awaited reversal of Roe occur, Alito will be there writing an opinion that stresses federalism, enhances the power of the states, uncreates an artificially created right, and is so well-reasoned (unlike Roe itself), that the precedent will stay in place for decades to come.
[+] Read More...

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Reversing Reverse Discrimination--Sotomayor Loses Another Round

Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor was just handed a reversal of her decision in the New Haven firefighters reverse discrimination case. Five of her potential brethren (and sistern?) on the high court decided that neutral testing requirements for promotion were not discriminatory merely because minorities, largely Black, did not score high enough for promotions.

In another 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court rejected Sotomayor's wit and wisdom in Ricci v DeStefano. The City of New Haven, Connecticut had established promotion examinations for its city firefighters which followed every rule mandated by state and federal authorities regarding racial and ethnic neutrality. In 2007, the examination was administered. Nineteen White firefighters and one Hispanic firefighter passed the test. None of the Black firefighters who took the test passed.

The city, fearing that it would be found in violation of some nebulous state or federal civil rights policy by granting the promotions to the successful firefighters and not to the unsuccessful ones, threw out the results. It had already been threatened with lawsuits by "civil rights activist" groups if the firefighters were promoted. Yet absolutely nobody was able to come up with a single shred of evidence that the test was in any way skewed by racial factors. They weren't objecting to the test--only to the results, which meant no Black firefighter would be promoted in this round.

When Bill Clinton nominated Lani Guinier as Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights, it turned out that she supported "results oriented" litigation. That was enough to disqualify her, and after Clinton expressed the appropriate amount of fake surprise about the views of his former Yale colleague, Guinier withdrew her name from consideration. Somehow Clinton had failed to notice that her nickname was The Quota Queen. Sotomayor has expressed exactly the same views, but despite the racial barriers which have continued to fall since Guinier's nomination, Sotomayor's view of the law is now highly acceptable, even commendable, in President Obama's eyes. Fortunately, the Supreme Court did not agree.

The successful firefighter candidates sued the city for discrimination when they were denied their promotions. For those of you who have read my posts in the past, you know that I use the term "reverse discrimination" only when referring to what other people have said. There is no reverse discrimination--only discrimination, and it's vile in all its many forms. The firefighters' suit claimed that New Haven was discriminating against them by deciding that the tests were unfair solely because none of the Black candidates passed.

A federal judge, Janet Bond Arterton, granted summary judgment for the defendant City of New Haven. "Summary judgment" means that the court did not review the evidence and testimony, but simply decided that the suit was invalid on its face. She stated simply in her opinion that no racial discrimination had occurred because the city didn't promote anyone of any race.

The firefighters then appealed to the U. S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. And there they ran afoul of "results-oriented" Sonia Sotomayor. In a one paragraph decision, Sotomayor praised the thorough, thoughtful and well-reasoned opinion of Arterton. Of course Arterton hadn't considered any of the evidence, and had ruled against the firefighters on grounds that had little or nothing to do with the pleadings and testimony. But these two wise ethnic female judges brought a perspective to the court that white males never could have. Hispanic male judge Jose Cabranes (batting .500 on the ethnic/sex scale) was not kind in his dissent to Sotomayor's opinion. He stated that the single-paragraph order issued by Sotomayor and the concurring judges ignored over 1800 pages of testimony and more than an hour of oral argument--ignoring the facts of the case entirely.

Cabranes went on to say "This per curiam opinion adopted in toto the reasoning of the District Court without further elaboration or substantive comment, and thereby converted a lengthy, unpublished district court opinion, grappling with significant constitutional and statutory claims of first impression, into the law of this Circuit." For those uninitiated in appellate law, that means that all the courts within the circuit were now expected to rule in accord with the Sotomayor decision without any guidance whatsoever as to what the legal reasoning was. In other words, Sotomayor has simply said, "here's the result you must reach, and let us worry about why you should reach that result.

Cabranes further said in his dissent that "The opinion failed to address the constitutional issues of the case, and the majority had ignored the facts of the case as well. And it did so in an opinion that lacks a clear statement of either the claims raised by the plaintiffs or the issues on appeal. Indeed, the opinion contains no reference whatsoever to the constitutional claims at the core of this case."

Interestingly, the Supreme Court justices were unanimous in agreement that the lower courts, including Sotomayor's, had failed entirely to consider whether there was a strong basis in evidence which would justify a departure from the race-neutral policies of the Constitution and applicable statutory and case law. Five of the justices determined that there was no such evidence to warrant a departure from standardized testing, and reversed Sotomayor's opinion.

Justice Kennedy, writing for the majority, said that regardless of the city's intentions, strong and compelling evidence indicated that it had made an illegal, race-based hiring decision. "In other words, there is no evidence--let alone the required strong basis in evidence [to throw out the tests]. No individual should face workplace discrimination based on race. As we have discussed at length [after reviewing the evidence that the lower courts failed to review], the process was open and fair."

Sotomayor and her mentor on the Supreme Court, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, want results, not openness or fairness, or even good logic. For them, public safety is not an issue when racial goals are not being met, no matter how hard the city tried. In her dissent, Ginsburg reaches an absolutely bizarre conclusion in order to ignore the evidence, testimony and arguments in the case. She simply twists the evidence to state that "Under the Civil Rights Act of 1964--the law in question--employers commit discrimination if their actions are not necessary for business or there is another way to avoid a racially discriminatory result." Never mind that the evidence demonstrated that the "business" to be conducted was public safety, and that no evidence was produced of any kind which demonstrated that there was another way to accomplish the civil rights goal short of endangering public safety by promoting those unqualified to make command decisions.

Ordinarily, Ginsburg and Sotomayor favor the old burden of proof whereby employers, once charged with discrimination, must prove they did not discriminate. The current standard that they usually would oppose is that the charge is not enough, and the plaintiff must prove actual discrimination. And yet, even applying that rule, the firefighters did prove exactly that, and all the lower courts simply and summarily ignored all the evidence which supported their claim.

I'll let Justice Alito's concurring opinion state what this was really all about. "New Haven's discrimination against the White and Hispanic firefighters was a case of political correctness run amok and the lower courts' [all the lower courts'] refusal to look at the facts had denied them justice."

This case is important on two counts. First, it establishes once again that Sotomayor is not fit to sit on the nation's highest court. Even the liberal justices admonished her for failing to review the evidence before issuing a summary judgment. In addition, the case is important because it is final. That means the Supreme Court has determined that the courts below were so totally wrong that the high court had to repair all the damage, set the precedent, and not return the case to the courts below for any further deliberation. From here on out, the Sotomayors of the legal world will at least have to pretend to review the facts, evidence and testimony before coming up with decisions that ignore the Constitution and sound legal principles.
[+] Read More...