Friday, July 9, 2010

Films: Down With The Apocalypse!!

There was a time when I used to enjoy a good end of the world movie. But I’ve gotten to the point where I really can’t stand them anymore. This has me a little perplexed. What’s changed my opinion about these movies? After careful deliberation, I’ve concluded that the nature of these films has changed: they no longer have a point except to present grotesque imagery. And that makes them kind of sick.

Apocalyptic films trace their history way back. Indeed, the term “apocalypse,” a Greek word meaning “lifting the veil,” derives from the Bible’s Book of Revelations, though every culture had its own version of the end of the world story. It seems that as a species, we are fascinated with our own demise. And I suppose that’s natural because humans are social creatures and we’re big on trying to control our own destinies. Apocalyptic stories sit at the crossroads of these two impulses, as they are warnings about what can go wrong if we let society do the wrong thing.

This, I think, is what made the early apocalyptic films so interesting: they were warnings, i.e. message movies. The writers/directors saw something in our world or in our behavior that troubled them, and they created their movies as a warning about what they saw. Hence, you had films warning about everything from the dangers of nuclear/biological/chemical weapons to the dangers of robots and automation to the dangers of not being able to cooperate to meet challenges to the dangers of divine retribution for our sins. And because these were message films, the majority of the film was about showing us both how we could avoid such a fate or, alternatively, how we could end up rushing head-long into it. In other words, they were lessons.

Now let me be clear: I am not saying that these films were all great or that I believed the messages. In fact, most of the messages were laughable, e.g. their “science” was usually truly awful, and the apocalypts’ interpretation of human nature was pathetic, they seem incapable of grasping that there is a good side to human nature that balances and checks the bad. But at least these films were working on exploring something worth exploring, and the themes were interesting: will weapon X be our undoing? If we give in to our darker sides, what kind of damage can we cause? How will humans respond to such horrors? Etc.

But today, this has all changed. And nothing shows this more than the change in what causes our demise in the films. In the past, our demise was always caused by something that society found acceptable, like our own chemical or nuclear weapons, or science that we marveled at even though we were not yet ready to control it. Because of this, these films always gave us something to think about. When Chuck Heston cursed us all in Planet of the Apes, we wondered if we could really knock ourselves down the food chain if we pushed the button. When we saw humanity enslaved by a computer in Colossus: The Forbin Project, we wondered how far we should trust computers to control our weapons. When Matthew Broderick nearly kill us all in War Games, we wondered how secure our weapons really were? And so on. In each instance, our comfort with the status quo was questioned, and we were asked if we really felt comfortable with things as they were.

Conversely, today the causes are either beyond our control (like an asteroid) or they are the result of criminal behavior by clichéd bad guys. Consequently, there is nothing for us to consider anymore. Indeed, while we may have wondered about the wisdom of hording nuclear weapons after seeing Fail Safe, no one thinks “gee, maybe we should make it more illegal for corporations to make killer, mutant viruses” after watching Resident Evil.

Thus, the nature of these films has changed before a single frame of film is even shot: modern apocalypse films all but wipe out the social commentary aspect of the genre.

Moreover, the focus of the story has changed. The older films dealt mainly with the events leading up to the disaster, with the intention being to warn us of the dangers we supposedly faced and how we could bring about our own demise as a result of those dangers. Even when these films did deal with the after-effects, it was done mainly to add emphasis to the story. By comparison, today’s apocalypse films are all about the after-effects. Indeed, whereas the older films were intended as critiques of human nature, the new films are slick CGI snuff films showing the many ways the film crew could come up with for killing human beings.

What this means is that whereas the older films served a purpose, the newer ones are purely gratuitous. In the older films, the slaughter, when shown, was intended to heighten the drama or to heighten the impact of the consequences of ignoring the director’s warning. But in the new films, the slaughter is what is being sold to you. It is the backdrop for an otherwise bland action story, and it is the action itself. The difference between these two approaches is the difference between a treatise on humanity and a book of gory pictures.

And I that’s why I don’t like apocalyptic films anymore. Even though I disagreed with the older ones (and found many of them laughable) at least they were earnest and the drama was interesting. They had a purpose. Today films have lost all of that. They have instead become mass snuff films, whose only purpose is to satisfy our bloodlust.

I guess I just don’t find that cool.


[+] Read More...

Thursday, July 8, 2010

Freedom of Approved Speech

Liberals are nothing if not strong advocates for free speech. Now, admittedly, sometimes they do accept a few restrictions on speech. . . such as speech codes on college campuses, hate crimes laws based on speech they don’t like, banning groups they don’t like from college campuses, banning people with opinions they don’t like from entering their countries, banning books with words they don’t like, blocking websites with “controversial opinions,” censoring radio broadcasts, outlawing blasphemy against Islam, censoring the internet, demanding that their opinions be given equal time on conservative shows, stopping corporations and people they don’t like from giving to politicians, blacklisting people with views they don’t like from certain professions, shouting down speakers they don’t like, disrupting meetings of people they don’t like, conspiring to keep opposing views out of “scientific” journals, taxing conservative websites to support liberal newspapers, firing people who espouse conservative views, removing religious symbols and words from courthouses, statehouses, and schoolhouses, regulating commercial speech, and a few others. But other than those very few instances, Liberals are staunch defenders of free speech.

That’s why it was so very, very strange to hear about the problem they’re having at various liberal websites like the Democratic Underground. Apparently, a few disloyalists are not enamored with the Democrats and our Kenyan overlord. And these dirty secret-fascists apparently have had the poor taste to actually express their views. Shocking!

Well, that’s not good for free speech or the Democratic cause. So the good people at the Democratic Underground have come up with a solution. From now on, you may continue to post all the free speech your bleeding heart desires, with the following exceptions:
• You may no longer post “over-the-top assertions of bad faith” by Obama or the Democrats

• You may not “advocate voting against Democrats, or in favor of third-party or GOP candidates.”

• You may not make “broad-brush smears against Democrats generally [or] broad expressions of contempt toward Democrats generally.”
Oh, and in case I forgot to mention, there are 59 more rules on what speech will be verboten.

Now I debated whether or not I should even mention this, seeing as how this is obviously tangential to the issue of freedom of speech. Indeed, except for a few fringe Hitler-lovers, I can’t imagine anyone would see this as limiting freedom of speech in any way, right? And I’m sure you feel the same way. . . after all, you don’t like Hitler. . .do you?

In any event, this whole thing has given me some ideas. I think it’s time we too expanded the freedom of speech at our stuffy website. So in the hopes of encouraging true free speech, I announce the new posting rules. From now on:
• You may not criticize Republicans in any way that uses words shorter than seven letters, or longer than six letters.

• You may no longer mention Pelosi’s Botox treatments. Humans need oxygen, vampires need blood, Big Bird needs meth, and Pelosi needs Botox. . . that’s how nature made us, and it’s just not right to turn that into a criticism.

• You may no longer mention Barack’s real middle name -- Trevor. Because that makes his initials BTO, which was not a very good band.

• Speaking of bands, no more threats against Lady Gaga. She is third in line for the British throne after all and we could use the support with a Commentarama Tax Bill we’re trying to get through Parliament.

• And no more poking fun at Joe Biden. I can’t prove it, but I know you’re all making up those quotes you keep attributing to him. . . no one can be that stupid.
If you live by these simple rules, then you won’t be jailed. If you don’t, then I’m going to write to the fishysnitch e-mail address about you and you’ll learn how much liberals love secret police departments.


[+] Read More...

Abigail Thernstrom Disagrees On The Black Panthers Cases

Never let it be said that all conservatives march in lockstep. I recently posted an article on the reprehensible dismissal of the Black Panther voter intimidation cases. Dr. Abigail Thernstrom, a member of the US Commission on Civil Rights and a solid conservative takes issue with those of us who felt this deserved serious scrutiny and a few lopped-off heads.

Dr. Thernstrom has been a strong advocate for civil rights the old-fashioned way. Equal treatment for all, regardless of race, creed, color, social station or economic class. So when she takes a stand quite different from mine, I can't simply dismiss her as being a kook. She is not. And I feel that if I am to justify my position, I must examine hers with a neutral eye (not easy to do for someone with my ego). I respectfully disagree, but she makes a point. Let's talk a bit about where she's coming from, and where she wants to go.

In the wake of the Black Panther controversy, Thernstrom says: "Forget about the New Black Panther Party case; it is very small potatoes. Perhaps the Panthers should have been prosecuted under section 11 (b) of the Voting Rights Act for their actions of November 2008, but the legal standards that must be met to prove voter intimidation--the charge--are very high." Fair enough. But just because a case is difficult doesn't automatically mean it shouldn't be pursued. More importantly, default judgments had already been entered in specific cases, so there's nothing left to prove except monetary damages--and that's the easy part.

"Too much overheated rhetoric filled with insinuations and unsubstantiated charges has been devoted to this case," says Thernstrom. I respectfully disagree. She bases her "overheated" accusation on the fact that "the two Panthers have been described as 'armed'--which suggests guns." No, it suggests armed--as in clubs and chains. Dr. Thernstrom has never been involved in a gang fight. She apparently doesn't know that those instruments can inflict serious bodily harm. The law is about the threat--the intimidation--not about an actual assault and battery. "Brandishing" is a charge all of its own, yet Dr. Thernstrom says "one of them was carrying a billy club, and it is alleged (actually it was proved) that his repeated slapping of the club against his palm constituted brandishing it in a menacing way." Yep--I'd certainly call that brandishing.

Here's where I think Dr. Thernstrom went over the cliff (on this single issue only): "Get a grip, folks. The New Black Panther Party is a lunatic fringe group that is clearly into racial theater of minor importance. It may dream of a large-scale effort to suppress voting . . . . But the Panthers have not realized their dream even on a small scale." When it comes to a basic American right such as voting, there is no "small scale," and just as it doesn't take a weatherman to know which way the wind blows, it doesn't take a genius to know that what the Panthers did in Phildelphia was voter-intimidation. There's absolutely no way to spin that into harmlessness.

It's also important to remember that these were civil, not criminal prosecutions against the Panthers. Dr. Thernstrom seems to be making the mistake of thinking that proving the cases beyond a reasonable doubt would be difficult if not impossible. But that is not the standard in civil prosecutions. Such suits require only proof by clear and convincing evidence, of which there was plenty.

So now that I've discussed why I think Dr. Thernstrom is wrong on the Black Panther cases, how do I go on to be almost effusive in my praise for her? I look to her record, which is one of bold support of equal rights and bold opposition to special rights, and her inability to remain silent in the face of massive injustice and race preferences. Her tenure on the Civil Rights Commission has included many ugly confrontations with the race-baiting leftist members. One of the most intense was Thernstrom's ongoing battle with former Chairman Mary Frances Berry who refused to seat a Bush appointee to the Commission and attempted to retain her own seat at the end of her term. One of Berry's statements particularly incensed Thernstrom: "Civil rights laws were not passed to protect white men and do not apply to them."

She might take issue with me on this, but I think two factors motivated her outburst on the Black Panther cases. First, after so many years on the Commission, Dr. Thernstrom has become just plain exhausted trying to rectify even the simplest and most obvious of civil rights violations. It has been a herculean task, and she can be forgiven for being dismissive of a series of cases which will probably end up going nowhere, given the nature of the Holder Justice Department and the passage of time.

Equally importantly, Dr. Thernstrom sees the possibility of major future confrontations over the Voting Rights Act, most specifically the ongoing problem of majority minority districts which wish to free themselves from earlier consent decrees that required minimum representation by minorities. The Holder Justice Department has consistently refused the pleas of nearly all black districts to be released from the consent decrees which were entered when whites completely controlled those districts. These decrees have ceased to serve their purpose, since the odds are extremely high that no matter which party or which philosophy prevails in one of those districts, the winner will almost certainly be a black person. And that was the sole purpose of the consent decrees in the first place.

The Holder Justice Department has also strongly stated that in the wake of the Census, it will actively support the maximum possible number of majority minority districts, whether they are under the consent decrees or not. This no longer simply guarantees black representation, it in reality nearly assures the perpetual election of Democrats. And this all flies in the face of the core civil rights belief that in a non-racist society, minorities would be elected to political office solely in numbers proportional to the black and Hispanic populations. By careful redistricting, the Holder people will be supporting artificially gerrymandered "all black" districts regardless of the actual distribution of the racial and ethnic groups over the larger picture of a given geographical area.

So long as the consent decrees continue, that means that in those districts, any consideration other than race will give rise to massive litigation and delays in holding elections, particularly when the office of the Attorney General (charged with allowing or disallowing release from the consents) is determined never to let a good consent decree go to waste. Requests for release from the decrees are routinely denied, despite what has frequently turned out to produce ludicrous results. This process is called "preclearance," and it only requires the disapproval of a very minor DOJ functionary.

Though Thernstrom (and I) believe that absent a major shift in the makeup of the US Supreme Court, it is substantially likely that Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act will ultimately be declared unconstitutional. But we both recognize how much serious damage can be done both to voting rights and racial relations between now and then. Thus, she considers the Black Panthers cases to be "small potatoes" because of the limited number of perpetrators and victims involved as compared with the vast potential mischief built into the plans of the Holder Justice Department as they relate to the Voting Rights Act. I concede that she has a point, but just because one issue may involve fewer people than a bigger issue, that doesn't mean it's small potatoes when major rights are involved. The Black Panthers weren't charged with spitting on the sidewalk, after all.

On July 5, I posted a piece about the Black Panthers, and one attorney specifically (even though half your comments still seem to be in the Blogger Black Hole). J. Christian Adams testified as scheduled, and though it was not a blockbuster, he did name a few names, referred to several others, and fully demonstrated that the dismissal of the Black Panthers cases was purely political. The Committee seems to be viewing the testimony with the same lack of enthusiasm shown by Dr. Thernstrom, though likely for entirely less noble reasons.

But there has been another development involving this attorney, and the "bigger picture" that Dr. Thernstrom was determined to call to the attention of the public. While Thernstrom emphasized the importance of the consent decrees and future gerrymandering, Adams has decided to go public with a related issue. Section 8 of the Federal Motor Voter Act specifically requires that voter registrars remove deceased and illegal voters from the voter rolls. A section chief at Holder's DOJ has apparently ordered the DOJ attorneys not to enforce this provision because "it would decrease voter participation." I'm afraid that there's no way to parody that remark because it is pure parody in and of itself. Yes, it's true. If dead people are forbidden to vote, participation will indeed go down. In Chicago alone, dead Democrats comprise 20 or 30 percent of the vote.

I mention this recent development for two reasons. First and most obviously, it will be interesting to see how Dr. Thernstrom feels that this facet of the law fits into the pending future voting disasters along with the consent decrees. But secondly, it is fascinating that Adams has decided that just being a good boy and doing his job, even at the risk of being fired, is not sufficient. He has now decided to go very public with his accusations. And he has proven he's a smart lawyer by pre-empting many future attacks on his character and abilities. He has used PajamasMedia to post his entire work record, which is comprised entirely of favorable to highly-favorable reviews by his superiors at DOJ, Democrats and Republicans alike.


[+] Read More...

Wednesday, July 7, 2010

Discussion: The Big 4-0

If you knew a conservative blogger who was turning the Big 4-0 tomorrow, what would you get them for their birthday? A red sports car? A tombstone? Or, alternatively, what would you want if you were turning the Big 4-0? Oh, and type louder. . . I think my hearing is going. [+] Read More...

Democratic Woes Worsen

The other day, I laid out the case for a Republican tidal wave in November. We now have new evidence to add to the pile. Indeed, things are not looking good for our donkey friends on any front. After a panicky weekend of stories about the effects of the faltering economy on Democratic prospects, we now get evidence of anger and chaos.
1. Chaos: Yet Another Bad Strategy
I’ve mentioned before that the Democrats are having a problem finding a strategy they can use to attract voters. They wanted to sell the Stimulus, but it went bust and made people insanely angry at the level of debt the Democrats piled onto the country. They wanted to sell the improving economy, but it didn’t improve. They had a jobs bill that didn’t create any jobs. They wanted to trumpet ObamaCare, but the people hated that. They wanted to rely on Financial Reform, but that’s a snoozer. They tried scapegoating Bush, but that’s not getting traction either.

And Obama is no help. In fact, he’s become so unpopular that Democrats won’t even be seen with him anymore, e.g. Russ Feingold who vanished off the face of the Earth when Obama came to Wisconsin the other day. Add in the BP thing, the McChrystal thing, the Arizona thing, the corruption thing, and you’ve got a serious problem with coming up with a message.

So what’s a Democrat to do? Well, the new plan is to turn the election into a race on local issues, i.e. avoid national issues entirely. But of course, there are two problems with this. First, they haven’t done anything better locally than they’ve done nationally. Secondly, midterm elections have always been a referendum on the incumbent party. Running on local issues just won’t work.
2. Anger: Fund Raising Blues
The Democrats three biggest sources of funds are lawyers, bankers, and unions -- in that order, and their biggest treasure trove of financing comes from New York. But things are going wrong for them in New York. Indeed, there have been several articles lately talking about how dire the Democrats’ relations with Wall Street and New York have become. Said one anonymous Democrat: “Clearly, it's an extremely difficult environment out there.”

There are three issues going on here:

First, many bankers are upset about being demonized by the Democrats during the Financial Regulation debate. Indeed, many banks have decided to sit out this fundraising cycle. Key Democratic supporter Goldman Sachs, for example, has refused to host or attend any fundraisers for Democrats. Said one banker:
“The fact is that the ink is not even dry on [financial regulation], and everyone in town is still getting fundraising requests from members of the conference committee and all sorts of other people who were beating up on Wall Street. It’s unseemly at best, and right now we are just not inclined to say ‘yes’.”
Said another:
“Sometimes their chutzpah just has no bounds. People like [Gillibrand] who didn’t stand up for us at all during the debate are certainly going to feel some pushback.”
Secondly, Jewish donors are upset at the way Obama treats Israel. Several off-the-record comments have confirmed that most of these donors have closed their checkbooks to the Democrats and, more significantly, a large number of them, who have previously said “I've never written a check to a Republican in my life,” are suddenly attending Republican fundraisers.

Third, Obama’s style has become a problem. Just as Obama treats everything American (or British) with disdain, he’s treating New York donors with disdain. This is something they aren't accustomed to. In fact, in the past, they had the Clintons who pandered to their every whim. Said one Washington Democrat:
“For the Clintons, these donors were part of their social circle. They vacationed with them, they had dinners with them. That's not the case for Barack.”
No, it's not. Obama has shown no interest in mixing with these people. Moreover, not only is he not showing them the love the Clintons did, he's actively attacking them:
“They were coddled and worked very hard. Now, they're not just told they're not needed but that they're part of the problem.”
And this disdain is hurting other Democrats as well, who are discovering that Obama's contempt is affecting their fundraising as well: “Obama doesn't care about [these donors], and it trickles down to the rest of the system.”

So how are the Democrats responding? Like they always do. . . by publically blasting the contributors. Said one Democrat, “The New York donor community is all ego driven,” and these complaints are simply from people who are upset about “not getting invited to movie night at the White House.” Way to improve relations!
3. The Unforgiving Public
Finally, the anti-Democratic-incumbent wave continues. Sen. Russ Feingold of Wisconsin was supposed to have an easy re-election. Apparently not. Two polls this week show that Feingold is only 2% ahead of his challenger (45% to 43%), Ron Johnson, a relatively unknown businessman from Oshkosh with no prior political experience.

What’s worse for Feingold, his approval ratings are equal to his disapproval ratings at 42%. Anything less than 50% support for an incumbent at this stage, usually spells disaster as undecideds tend to break for the challenger.

Add in Toomey’s growing lead over Sestak, and it suddenly looks like the Republicans might capture the Senate after all, especially with the excitement edge benefiting Republicans.

All of this is simply more evidence of what is becoming an obvious trend. The Democrats are in trouble. The polls say it. The MSM’s defensiveness says it. The Democrats’ panic says it. And now the Democrats’ donors are saying it. And the Democrats don’t have a clue how to respond to any of this.


[+] Read More...

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

Why There Aren't Any Jobs. . .

“That’s funny, they’re dustin' for jobs where there ain’t no jobs.”

-- North by Northwest. . . sort of.

The Democrats are worried. They expected the American economy to start producing jobs galore by this point in the election cycle no matter what they did. They were wrong. The economy has lost 7.9 million jobs since the recession began. Joe Biden says those jobs are gone forever and will never return. And it's hard to disagree: as long as the Democrats are running the show, those jobs won’t return.

Most of these jobs vanished because the economy entered a recessionary period. Recessions are a normal and necessary part of the economic cycle. In recessions, businesses cut the fat out of their operations, consumers retrench and make their own balance sheets more healthy, and poorly run companies go under, freeing up the resources they were wasting for better uses. This usually results in a strong period of growth once you emerge from the recession. Yet, this hasn’t happened.

Part of the reason is that this recession was worse than most. In fact, it was basically a depression. It also had a different character than most recessions because this one was caused by consumers living way beyond their means because a bubble in the housing market made them feel much richer than they actually were, and they spent accordingly. Now that housing prices have crashed, consumers have lost that source of credit and their imaginary wealth. This will take some time to balance out again, meaning prolonged trouble for the economy.

But that’s not the only problem. Over the past two years, the Democrats have piled insane levels of debt onto the American taxpayer. This inflated interests rates, dried up credit, and weakened the dollar. All of this made it more expensive for the already-hurting consumer to spend. The Democrats then enacted a series of tax hikes and new regulations, each of which further reduced the desire of consumers to spend and made it more expensive for producers to produce. They also passed various measure that made credit more expensive. Basically, the Democrats kicked the economy right where it was injured.

What the Democrats were betting on was that the economic cycle was strong enough that whatever they did wouldn’t stop growth from returning. In a growth cycle, that might have been true: their policies would have slowed growth, but might not have stopped growth entirely. But with consumers already on the verge of collapse, this was the worst possible time to impose growth depressing and consumer crushing policies.

And that’s not even the worst of it. The Democrats have added to the misery by talking big but simultaneously trying to remain vague. Indeed, they have outlined an aggressive leftwing agenda in principle, but they have been too afraid to outline the specifics. Even when they have passed bills, they usually kicked the important decisions on the details down the Executive agencies level.

Why does this matter? Because before employers will hire or expand (which leads to hiring), they want certainty. If they don’t know what regulations are coming, then they won’t hire and they won’t expand because they can’t determine if it makes sense to do so. The Democrats’ big, vague talk leaves employers fearful of what is coming and uncertain as to its effects. Hence, they simply won’t hire or expand until they get some certainty. In fact, they’d be crazy to do so. But certainty won't come for another couple years until the relevant agencies issue their regulations.

The Democrats don’t understand this. Indeed, right now they are in a near-panic about the lack of jobs, but they don’t have a clue what to do. Some of them want another stimulus, even as their own side finally admits that the first three or four stimuluses didn’t work -- mainly because they showered money on non-job-producing projects like supporting state debt. Others want a “jobs bill,” which is another name for a stimulus bill. Some just want to put their heads in the sand and blame Bush. . . seriously, they started a new campaign this weekend to blame Bush. Even their friends in the media have dutifully created polls to show that the public blames Bush for the economy.

How sad.

In any event, the Republicans should take a lesson here. When they get back in power, they need to resuscitate the consumer and employers. That means tax cuts, and it means providing certainty so that people can hire or expand with confidence.

In the meantime, enjoy the show as the Democrats run around like maniacs beating a very dead horse.


** Update: Interestingly, after I wrote this, several liberal blogs tried to explain why there were no jobs. The answer they came up with was "after the last 12 months of change, businesses aren't certain yet how the business environment has changed." That's close, but not quite there. The problem isn't that businesses don't understand the last 12 months yet, the problem is they don't know what the next 12 months will look like.

[+] Read More...

The UN Loves Women--No, Really.

You can always tell how much the United Nations likes a subject by how many commissions, committees, discussion groups, confabs, and entities are created to embrace the subject. It wasn't sufficient that they have allowed the repressive regime of Iran on the Commission on the Status of Women. So just in case you didn't think they considered women sufficiently important, the UN is now creating "U N Women."

What is that, you ask? Well, officially it's the United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women. Now are you convinced of how much the UN cares? It could be worse, I suppose. Unlike the Commission on the Status of Women which is comprised almost entirely of members chosen by geographical area, the "Entity" will have a slightly higher representation based on the percentage of money contributed to the UN. So the United States and Japan will lead the field of states which get seats based on monetary contributions. But they'll still be outnumbered by the states which get seats based solely on geography.

So why create yet another UN group to study the international condition of women? That should probably be obvious from the divergence in representation on the entity. If there's one thing the United Nations does well, it's to suck money out of the pockets of the western democracies. With Iran and other repressive regimes leading the Status Commission, the only way to sucker the West (America particularly) into funding another meaningless and counterproductive activity is to give them extra seats on a newly-created money burning machine.

Previous American administrations have ranged from mildly complicit to openly hostile to the United Nations bodies which claim to be one thing but do quite another. How much do you think the Status Commission will be doing to improve the lot of women in Muslim and sub-Saharan African nations? But this knowledge slows down the influx of money to the UN. And we are now two years into the "we are the world, we are the people" Obama administration. So let's create another whole new body purporting to stand for women's progress and make sure the big bucks nations are well-represented so they can feel better about throwing more money down another UN rathole.

Presently, aside from the Status Commission, there are several small, less grand-sounding UN entities which cover some of the same ground. But as we know, the UN is all about efficiency. So those entities, which currently cost about $500 million annually to accomplish nothing for women will be replaced by a much grander entity that will spend an estimated $1 billion annually to do nothing for women than was previously done for half the price.

One cannot help but wonder how long after the Western suckers have disgorged their capitalist wealth on the new entity will they discover that somehow the entity has come to be dominated by the champions of women's liberation such as Saudi Arabia, Libya, Iran, Sudan and the johnny-come-lately Afghanistan. I'm still waiting for the creation of a multibillion dollar UN "entity" to study the empowerment of gays, lesbians, transgendered and transsexual folks. I'm sure my old home and original site of the United Nations, San Francisco, will be among the first to commit itself to such a chimerical concept.
[+] Read More...

Monday, July 5, 2010

Maybe Now We'll Get The Facts

I've discussed the Holder Justice Department's reprehensible dismissal of the voter intimidation cases against the New Black Panthers previously: Meet Your Political DOJ Leaders and Hold That Tiger--Er, Panther. DOJ has continued to stonewall the Civil Rights Commission concerning the dismissals, but we may get a break this week. Pictured are some of the Panthers "protecting the polls" in Philadelphia.

In short, the career professional lawyers in the Department of Justice had dead-bang winner cases against the New Black Panthers and their thuggish law-breaking at the polls in Philadelphia in November, 2008. In fact, the Department already had two default judgments firmly in hand. By the time the rest of the cases were ready to come before the courts, a strange thing happened. The cases, under the new leadership of Eric Holder, were suddenly and ignominiously dismissed by the Department, including those it had already won.

I'm not going to pretend for a second that anyone with an IQ above room temperature doesn't know the reasons behind that decision. But as all lawyers and most fans of TV lawyer shows understand, knowing something is not the same as proving it. When queried on the reasons by the U. S. Commission on Civil Rights, the Obama-Holder Justice Department went into full defensive mode. Dissent was immediately silenced. Demands from the Commission were ignored. Those few responses to the Commission which were issued by Holder were both patronizing and unethical. Those career lawyers in the Department who had put the legal complaints together were threatened with banishment to the professional equivalent of Siberia if they attempted to justify their successful litigation against the Panthers.

Several of the threatened attorneys caved in, while other continued to speak up privately and were rewarded with their new positions at the DOJ gulags. Much of this, though not particularly noble, is understandable. These were career lawyers who had devoted their professional lives to the Department and didn't wish to see their life's work end so suddenly. But a few refused to follow Holder's orders to remain silent on the issue, and have left the Department.

One of those brave souls, J. Christian Adams, resigned when the DOJ political lawyers, likely under the direct orders of Attorney General Eric Holder, forbade him to testify truthfully before the Civil Rights Commission. Adams, a careerist lawyer in the Voting Rights Division of the DOJ, was one of the attorneys directly involved in the successful litigation against the Panthers. Adams has said recently, among other condemnations of Holder's department, that he could simply no longer tolerate the DOJ's horrendously skewed record of failure to pursue black-on-white crimes and civil rights violations.

Like Obama, Holder loves to speak in grandiose terms about racial relations, but also like Obama, he is entirely lacking in the Founders' concept of equal justice under law or Martin Luther King's belief in character rather than color. Holder seems determined to right wrongs committed more than forty years ago by punishing people who had nothing to do with suppression of the black vote in the South. On the other hand, he seems equally determined to ignore current violations of both Civil Rights and Voting Rights legislation so long as the perpetrators are the alleged descendants of those who actually were victims of discrimination.

So far, Adams has already specifically named two of the leftist political functionaries in DOJ whom I mentioned in my earlier articles. Loretta King and Steve Rosenbaum, says Adams, were instrumental in the suppression of further prosecution and dismissal of the cases already won. We will have to wait for the hearings to find out if he will specifically name Holder himself. I find it almost impossible to believe that they could have done their dirty deeds without the approval of Holder, but Adams is a professional, and he won't accuse Holder himself unless he has evidence. Let's hope he does.

I'm bringing this information to you for three reasons. The first is that the whole rotten mess offends my civil rights activist soul. Is this why we took on redneck Southern sheriffs, high-pressure firehoses and vicious police dogs in the 60s? The second is that after a personal career in law for many years, seeing selective prosecution reappear in a new form offends my entire love of the Constitution and the rule of law.

The third reason is far more mundane. I bring this to you because the MSM won't. They succeeded in ignoring or burying the first round of contention when the legal cases were dismissed. Then they totally ignored the series of major confrontations between Holder's department and the Civil Rights Commission. And as of this writing, I have not seen a single report in the liberal press or on the liberal "news" stations that what could be extremely damaging testimony by a knowledgeable insider is about to take place.

Adams is scheduled to testify tomorrow (Tuesday) before the Commission. He's a quiet, apolitical and thoughtful lawyer who has not sought the glare of public fame. Perhaps he should have. If his testimony comes even close to the blockbuster whistle-blowing expose that I expect it will, the complete lack of public knowledge of the event would mean another victory for the left's race-baiting extra-legal unconstitutional racial discrimination. And even if it doesn't rise to that level, I salute a man who was brave enough to stand up to the high-volume intimidation thrown at him by Holder and his crowd of unprofessional leftist pseudo-lawyers at the department charged with protecting us from lawlessness. Well done, thou good and faithful servant.
[+] Read More...

How Not To Win Friends Or Influence People

I’ve made a living out of finding ways to convince judges and juries that my clients are irresistibly right. It’s not an easy thing to do, especially since most people who come to lawyers are usually only about half right. Making this all the harder, the other side has an attorney too, and their job is to prove that my client couldn’t be more wrong. But I’ve had an advantage that has paid off time and time again, because I know something that seems to escape most attorneys and almost all bloggers. And that’s what I want to talk about today.

What is this magical knowledge? Simple: I know that people are suspicious of hyperbole. So when the other guy is whining how granting my client’s claim will cause the earth to crash into the sun, or they are foaming at the mouth about how my client eats children and I’m Satan’s third cousin, I’ve just go about my business and carefully lay out a logical and clearly reasoned case for why my client is right. I can’t think of a time this hasn’t worked.

I first discovered this principle when I was doing a clerkship for a group of judges. As I read through literally hundreds of briefs, I slowly realized that the most convincing briefs were the simplest, the most direct, the ones that laid out their reasoning with limited extraneous garbage. In fact, despite the lack of “big” and angry words, these briefs were quite compelling. They presented an argument. . . it made sense. . . I could think of no counter argument. . . winner. But the other guys, the ones who love hyperbole, offered nothing of value. Indeed, once they began rambling about how something is the greatest threat ever, it became impossible to take anything else they said seriously.

And the judges I worked for felt the same. None of them gave any credence to the hyperbolists. Some even ignored their arguments entirely. Others actively held the hyperbole against them, on the presumption that the hyperbole was evidence of a lack of substance, i.e. if they had a valid argument, they would have used it.

Since that time I’ve observed that this same principle holds true in other facets of life. If you’ve heard the expression, “methinks thou doth protest too much,” then you’ll know what I mean. Take Al Gore: he didn’t just deny what this woman is claiming, he “emphatically denied it.” But people who are innocent don’t “emphatically” deny, they just deny. They don’t say “and I really really mean it.” They just mean it. To say that you “really” mean it, implies that you usually lie, but this time we're supposed to trust you. No sale.

Bloggers are worse. Indeed, I am truly distressed by much of what I see in the blog world -- left and right. Look at this example from my inbox:
“These are desperate times for America, unless we ______ we will fall.”
Talk about a lack of perspective. This guy was actually talking about opposing financial regulation. At least a couple of you read the financial regulation article the other day, did you see anything in that financial reform bill which will cause American to fall? The Civil War, sure. Back when the Nazis wanted to enslave the world, or when the Soviets wanted to blow us off the map in a thousand atomic fireballs, yeah, that was a time we could legitimately say that we were facing desperate times and America might fall. But today?

And he continues:
“The socialists who at one time felt emboldened now feel cornered and threatened. As you read this, the Globalists, with all of their vast resources are organizing to fight Conservative Patriots, tooth and nail. The Army of Darkness will not be defeated easily; they lust for control of our beloved Nation. They know, if we falter on just one issue they can win all!”
Army of Darkness? Dude, I love that film! As for the rest of this pathetic crap, give me a break. This is the same garbage that the fringe was whining about when they knew that Clinton was about to turn us into a socialist utopia, when they knew that Carter was secretly planning to hand the world over to the Soviets, when they knew that Reagan had gone insane and was trying to disarm us in the face of the Soviet Union, when they knew that George Bush I was doing the bidding of some secret society, and so on. This is paranoid bullcrud.

Obama is doing some very bad things that will reduce certain freedoms (notably freedom of speech), injure our economy with increased regulation, probably bankrupt the government (ironically, putting an end to the dreams of big government), and increase racial tensions. But none of these will end our democracy. In fact, in our history, we’ve had much worse regulations, higher taxes, and nastier race relations than anything Obama is proposing. So get some perspective.

And even if this paranoia was close to correct, this guy is discrediting his own argument because what he presents is shrill, panicky and so-obviously-overstated and without substance that no one will believe it. This guy is like the attorney trying to assure the judge that enforcing my client's contract will cause the earth to crash into the moon. . . if not the sun. People tune out right at the get go with this kind of garbage.

Want proof? Think about it this way, the left had several legitimate grievances against Bush (in fact, even rightists were detailing them in op-ed pieces). But you didn’t give the left any credence, did you? In fact, you probably never even listened to them, did you? Yet you probably think of yourself as having an open mind, right? So why didn’t you listen to anything they said? The answer is simple: when they started their argument like this. . .
“The fascists who at one time felt emboldened now feel cornered and threatened. As you read this, the Globalists, with all of their vast resources are organizing to fight Working Americans, tooth and nail. The Army of Darkness will not be defeated easily; they lust for control of our beloved Nation. They know, if we falter on just one issue they can win all!”
. . . you tuned right out because you knew this was nothing but far-left fringe hate. You knew they had nothing of value to offer. So why would you think that our side saying the same things would receive a better response?

Trust me on this, people are willing to be told what to believe, but they want to believe that they reached that conclusion themselves. When you try to hit them over the head with fringemania, all you achieve is making yourself look like a nutjob.

Fellow conservatives, please stop using words like grave danger, outrage, horrific, despicable, and evil. Stop saying we've never faced anything worse. And if you’re going to call someone a ____ist, at least make sure they actually fit the definition, and even then think twice before doing it. Always ask yourself: “does this help my argument, or does this just turn people off?”

No go forth and persuade. . .

[+] Read More...

Saturday, July 3, 2010

Our Lives, Our Fortunes and Our Sacred Honor

Philadelphia
JULY 6th. 1776.

Sir,

The Congress, for some time past, have had their attention occupied by one of the most interesting and important subjects, that could possibly come before them or any other assembly of men.


Although it is not possible to foresee the consequences of human actions, yet it is, nevertheless, a duty we owe ourselves and posterity, in all our public councils, to decide in the best manner we are able, and to leave the event to that Being who controls both causes and events, to bring about his own determinations.

Impressed with this sentiment, and at the same time fully convinced that our affairs may take a more favorable turn, the Congress have judged it necessary to dissolve the connection between Great Britain and the American Colonies, and to declare them free and independent States, as you will perceive by the in closed DECLARATION, which I am directed by Congress to transmit to you, and to request you will have it proclaimed at the head of the army in the way you shall think most proper.

Agreeably to the request of Congress, the Committee of Safety of this Colony have forwarded to you ten thousand flints, and the Hints at Rhode Island are ordered to be sent to you immediately.

It is with great pleasure I inform you, that the militia of this Colony, of Delaware Government, and Maryland, are, and will be every day in motion, to form the Flying Camp, and that all the militia of this Colony will soon be in the Jerseys, ready to receive such orders as you shall please to give them.

I have written to Governor Cooke, to engage immediately, and send forward as fast as possible, fifty ship-carpenters to General Schuyler, for the purpose of building vessels on the Lakes. Fifty have already gone from hence on that business.

The Congress having directed the arms, taken on board the Scotch transports, to be sent to you. I have written to the agents in Rhode Island and Massachusetts Bay, to forward them immediately.

The enclosed copy of a letter from Mr. Green, I am directed to forward, by Congress, with a request that you will order such parts of the stores, therein mentioned, to New York, as you shall judge proper.

I have the honor to be, Sir, with perfect esteem, your most obedient and very humble servant,

JOHN HANCOCK, President


This letter was sent to Gen. George Washington in New York and attached to it was the official Declaration of Independence which Washington read to his troops on July 9, 1776. Similar letters were sent to representatives in all thirteen colonies and read in every town square - this Declaration signed by fifty-six men who "...for the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our fortunes and our sacred Honor".

This now-famous "assembly of men" fought valiantly to see the birth of a new nation and to a new form of government - a government of the people, by the people, and for the people. But they did not do it alone. There were countless unknown men, women, and children who fought right along side them, and many gave their lives, fortunes, and sacred honor for that same cause.

So, as you watch the fireworks and eat your hotdogs, raise up your frosty mug of Sam Adams Summer Ale (and raise Old Glory too), and give a thought to the all of the long forgotten citizen-soldiers who fought for the idea of Freedom, so that we can have the reality. And maybe raise one for those who are fighting for it today...

Happy Independence Day everyone!



[+] Read More...

What Were The Editors At National Review Thinking?

William F. Buckley must be rolling over in his grave. National Review departed from its normal policy of not endorsing candidates in primaries. That would not be such a terrible thing if there had been a particularly desirable conservative that the editors couldn't resist endorsing. But they chose to endorse, gulp, John McCain in the Republican senatorial primary in Arizona.

Fortunately, some of the collegiality that Buckley encouraged at National Review is still in place. Which means that their regular contributors are free to disagree with the editors within the pages of the magazine. Andrew McCarthy wasted no time taking advantage of this freedom of dissent by calling the editors to task in no uncertain terms.

There are two good reasons why a publication such as National Review should not endorse primary candidates except under extraordinary circumstances. A candidate not endorsed by NR who ultimately wins the primary could easily become an enemy of the publication, damaging its message. This is largely because the left looks for any signs of dissension among conservative ranks, and exploits them with the complicity of the mainstream media. On the other hand, if a solid conservative candidate loses to the moderate or semi-liberal candidate NR has endorsed, many conservatives will blame the magazine in the event of a narrow win by the magazine's pick.

General objections to endorsements in primaries aside, McCarthy is just plain ticked that the editors decided to diverge from their usual policy in order to endorse an unworthy candidate. Aside from running what may be the worst campaign for president that I've seen in my lifetime, McCarthy joins me in seriously questioning McCain's regular election year right turn which is always followed after the election by his "maverick" love fests with the Democrats. And while we're at it, let's face it. John McCain is not exactly the brightest crayon in the box.

In addition, McCain is running against a candidate, J. D. Hayworth, who seems to have strong conservative credentials and has gained adherents by going to the people with a conservative message that is unlikely to change the day after the election. It would probably have been equally unwise of NR to endorse Hayworth, but at least they would have erred on the side of conservative caution. Instead, they picked a candidate who has consistently talked conservative during election cycles then turned squishy progressive immediately thereafter.

McCain's favorite historical Republican is Teddy Roosevelt. Anyone who know his history knows that despite his many good qualities, TR was a dedicated member of the progressive movement. Woodrow Wilson Lite, if you will. As McCarthy points out, the editors know this fact, and felt it necessary to introduce their endorsement with the words "it would be an understatement to say NR has not always agreed with Sen. John McCain's judgment." That is about as much of an understatement as is journalistically possible. Except for some occasional agreement about the necessity of war in America's defense, and a few other minor issues, National Review has practically always disagreed with McCain's judgment, usually very harshly.

Can you imagine William F. Buckley endorsing a candidate as bereft of conservative thinking as John McCain? Guilt by association is commonly derided without much thinking going into the derision. After all, Ben Franklin said it very plainly: "He who lies down with dogs shall rise up with fleas." By his friends shall ye know him. So let's take a quick look at some of McCain's longtime friends. In 2000, during another presidential primary run, McCain proclaimed that if he should be elected, he would immediately seek the advice and counsel of John Kerry, the ultraliberal junior senator from Massachusetts. He would also have tapped genius Senator Joe Biden, and best of all, as his national security adviser, he promoted the name of Zbigniew Brzezinski (the idiot who advised Jimmy Carter on how to handle Iran). In 2004, McCain basked in the glory of the possibility of being chosen as the vice presidential running-mate for Democrat Kerry.

Despite their long history of opposition to most of McCain's political stumbling-about, the editors still stated that "McCain, though not reliable, is usually on the conservative side of national controversies." Say what? That must have been one helluva cocktail party that turned into an endorsement session. To bolster their support of McCain, they felt it incumbent on them to say that Hayworth is not obviously a more exemplary statesman than McCain. They would have been much closer to the truth if they had said that Hayworth hasn't been pretending to be a statesman for anything like the number of years McCain has put into the effort.

Let's take a look at some of the conservative stands McCain has taken (with tongue planted firmly in cheek). The editors used weasel-words to describe McCain's stand on taxes. "He has never voted for a broad-based tax increase." OK, but what about his vociferous opposition to the Bush tax cuts? And how about his very leftist-sounding rhetoric about the tax cuts, using words that come right out of the class warfare Democratic playbook? As McCarthy points out, McCain doesn't need to support an outright tax increase, he can simply stick to his opposition to the cuts, wait for them to expire, and work to make sure they aren't reinstated. In effect, if not in form, a huge tax increase.

Like McCarthy, I'm a legal conservative and originalist. So is National Review, most of the time. McCain is not, even if he can't pronounce originalist. Again, NR weaseled out on McCain and the judiciary. "McCain has voted for every conservative on the Supreme Court, and he has a long pro-life record." It's only a quibble, but McCain did not vote for Justice Scalia, since he wasn't a senator yet. But the simple fact is that McCain votes for just about any nominee to the Supreme Court, regardless of the judicial philosophy of the nominee or the politics of the president making the nomination. He both voted for and had kind words to say about Justices Kennedy, Souter, Ginsburg and Breyer, whose views on abortion vary from it being a constitutionally protected "choice" to partial birth abortion being a constitutional necessity in some cases.

In the political arena, McCain has done almost as much damage to the pro-life movement. He filed lawsuits to use his very own unconstitutional campaign-finance law to prevent a pro-life advocacy group from criticizing his partner in free speech suppression, leftist Senator Russ Feingold. And McCain's love of center stage has propelled him to great heights of accommodation with the left. In order to quash filibuster threats against Bush conservative appointees to the federal bench, McCain formed the "Gang of 14" to effect "compromise." Ultimately, almost none of Bush's best appointees got past the confirmation process, and those seats on the federal bench are now rapidly being filled by activist, pro-abortion, living Constitution advocates put forward by Barack Obama.

McCain also supported government funding of fetal stem-cell research, ignoring all the conservative and religous arugments about the destruction of human embryos. He has regularly supported massive amnesty for illegal aliens (except at election time, of course). He is not at all exercised by the concept of cap 'n tax, and at times (even recently) has used the "settled science" language of the left to promote green legislation in order to stop the anthropomorphic global warming that has been thoroughly debunked. And let's not forget that besides McCain-Feingold, there was McCain-Kennedy. McCain always had a particular affinity for the "liberal lion" (and underwater motorist) from Massachusetts.

On national security, he did support the surge in Iraq as well as the proposed surge in Afghanistan. But as McCarthy points out, without the determination and ability to win outright victory, the surges only prevent a "short-term ignominious defeat by replacing it with a long-term ignominious defeat." McCain's inability to sort out his own personal experiences in Vietnam of being tortured from recent practices in the Middle East, and without the intellectual rigor to make the distinction for harsh interrogation methods, joined the chorus of leftist Democrats wishing to indict CIA operatives for using techniques that had been approved by both the president and Congress. He joined in applauding the Obama executive order to stop all harsh interrogation techniques while providing civilian legal protections to foreign terrorists.

So will the real conservative John McCain kindly step forward so that National Review could point him out to us? In selecting McCain for the endorsement, the editors completely ignored the multiple horrendous policy mistakes McCain has made, along with his very unstatesmanlike outbursts of foul language and foul temper publicly displayed against people with whom he had a disagreement. Yet in order to proclaim McCain the more exemplary statesman, they managed to find one misstep that Hayworth made before he was a public official. Hayworth, as a private, paid spokesman for an infomercial, instructed people how to get "free money" from the government. At the time Hayworth was doing that, McCain was fostering legislation which actually did provide free money.

As McCarthy points out, Hayworth would be on the same side of the fence as National Review on freedom of political speech, immigration, interrogations, bailouts, cap 'n tax, tax cuts, keeping Gitmo open, and embryonic stem cell research. McCain stands with National Review's editorial policy on none of those issues. Even NR's editor Rich Lowry referred more than once to McCain's "statesmanship" as shenanigans and "dizzying political shape-shifting."

I'm sure that in the next few days, the editors will have put together a defense of their chimerical support for John McCain. I'm also sure it will be very lame. As McCarthy aptly put it: "Arizonans can figure out which candidate would best serve them without the help of National Review's editorial board. Primary endorsements push us into the spin business, and if we're going to spin, McCain is not the place to start."
[+] Read More...

Friday, July 2, 2010

Characters Who Are Too Stupid To Live

I’ve mentioned several times the importance of maintaining enough realism within a film that the audience can suspend its disbelief and accept the story as true. And there are many things that can kill the realism of films, everything from continuity errors to stunts that don’t seem real to plot points that don’t make sense. But the crème de la crème is the character who is too stupid to live.

The character who is too stupid to live is a character who does stupid, inexplicable and/or dangerous things apparently just to advance the plot. Examples abound. In fact, if you are a movie character, you might be too stupid to live if:
• You go skinny-dipping right after finding your friend chopped to pieces by the indestructible serial killer the radio keeps talking about...

• You knock down the evil kickboxer and then turn your back to do a victory dance, even as the crowd points to the villain as he rises up after grabbing a weapon...

• You hand over key evidence for safekeeping to the guy who is laughing manically...

• You and your ninja friends surround the hero, but then you all wait your turn to fight the hero...

• You are a villain who chooses the Rube Goldberg method for killing the hero and then leaves before the job is done...

• You overcome the first armed guard with an incredible combination of luck and stupidity on the part of the guard, but then you don’t think to pick up his gun to help you in the rest of your escape...

• You see your friend’s body ripped apart and covered in werewolf hair, but you decide there is no danger because there’s no such thing as werewolves. . . as if that somehow invalidates the fact that something used your friend as a chew toy...

• Ditto on those of you who think that zombie that used to be your friend Rick is coming to pick your brain, rather than eat it...

• You say the words: “let’s split up” for no apparent reason when people around you are disappearing...

• You’ve ever said the words: “Turn around? I’m not falling for that!” when there are dinosaurs or purple people eaters in the ‘hood. . .
I can accept characters with poor judgment and people who make mistakes in the heat of the moment. Indeed, stress causes people to do stupid things. Some get confused, others are overcome by fear; some freeze, some run, some do stupid things. Indeed, they have found that in true moments of crisis (like an airline crash) a small percentage of the population will do truly bizarre things like collecting their luggage or picking fights.

But when you’re talking about people in films who have time to think, you need to make sure the characters act with some sense of self-preservation. And if they don’t, then you need to explain why not and you need to lay the ground work for that.

In that regard, the one thing I have never bought into is “the jerk” as explanation. You know the guy, he’s introduced as the conservative businessman who yells and screams and talks about his worship of money from the opening frame. When he’s confronted with danger, he decides to ignore all good advice and do something incredibly stupid because. . . well, he’s a jerk. . . he’s like that. That doesn’t make sense. Even the biggest jerk has a sense of self-preservation.

An offshoot of this, which I also don’t like, can be seen in the Ron Weasley character in the Harry Potter books. By the third book, Weasley had really stopped acting like an independent human being with his own personality and life. Instead, he became a vehicle to move the plot. If Harry was too close to doing something that would solve the puzzle, Ron would appear, encourage him to act irresponsibly, and then leave. If Harry needed a push in a different direction, Ron appears, gives the push, and then leaves. Basically, whatever needed to be done to keep Harry moving forward with the story, Ron would provide it whether it made sense or not. Indeed, many of the things he did made no sense except as ways to move Harry through the plot.

I am a firm believer that every character in a movie or book should stand on their own. They should have their own motivations, their own desires, and they should act accordingly. If that means it takes a little more thought to get them alone with the werewolf or to get the hero to the next plot point, then so be it. Audiences see through characters who are merely plot convenience devices.

That’s my thinking.

[+] Read More...

Question: Interview Abuse!

You may recall the Commentarama Guide to Interviewing. Well, I thought it was time to update the old manual, and what better resource to exploit than our readers! So tell me, what questions would you ask if you could during an interview? [+] Read More...

Supremes Get Guns Right, Reasoning Wrong

Just in case you're wondering why I picked that particular gun to start a post on the recent Supreme Court decision on gun ownership, it just happens to be my own handgun--a Colt .357 Magnum Mark V Trooper. I can't keep up with Dirty Harry, since I'd get a hernia carrying his .44 Magnum.

On June 28, the United States Supreme Court expanded the individual gun ownership right it found in the Heller federal jurisdiction to the states in McDonald vs. Chicago. The onerous gun ownership laws in Chicago were nearly identical to those struck down in Washington DC as a result of Heller. But the latter decision involved only gun ownership and possession in federal jurisdictions, and we had to await the McDonald decision to find out if the high court would expand the right to state jurisdictions.

Those of you who have read my legal posts in the past may remember that I consider the reasoning behind a court decision to be as important, if not more important, than the actual majority opinion itself. And the McDonald decision is one of those landmark cases that reached a result I strongly approve of using legal reasoning with which I almost entirely disagree. Using the wrong reasoning to get the "right" result usually leads to years of litigation over matters which were not intended to relate to the decision, and also often erode or alter the very right the decision purports to protect.

As an example of what I mean, when I was teaching constitutional law, I used to wake up the nodding students by stating "Brown v Board of Education was wrongly decided." Since I taught in liberal schools in multiethnic and multiracial arenas, that always got their attention. The automatic assumption upon hearing that statement was "this guy believes that Southern militant racial segregation should have continued unabated." Nope. But it gave me the opportunity to teach them that sometimes a Supreme Court decision creates as much confusion as it resolves.

The high Court in Brown could [and should] have ended public school racial segregation once and for all, simply and effectively, by deciding on the basis that "the Constitution forbids the government to discriminate on the basis of race, creed, color, national origin, or prior condition of servitude." Period. But the Court felt it had to make a grandiose statement, and used the words of [then] ACLU lawyer Thurgood Marshall: "Separate is inherently unequal." That's not an announcement of law--it's a social opinion, based on no solid ground other than "it sounds right," and litigation that has next-to-nothing to do with racial discrimination has flowed from that one statement ever since.

The decision which indeed did end racial segregation in the public schools, at least eventually, raised all kinds of wonderful legal playthings for lawyers to fool with right up to today. There used to be a lot of schools which were boys schools and girls schools. But separate is inherently unequal, isn't it? So most public schools separated by sex were banned, and the concept worked its way up through the college and university levels. Severely handicapped children need special care, whether the handicap is physical, mental or both. There used to be many caring school districts which made special arrangements for those children and put them into separate classrooms and provided separate accommodations for them. But, let's not forget, separate is inherently unequal. So we've gone through years of litigation and "mainstreaming" of the severely handicapped into regular classrooms.

And of course, sports were affected as well. Not only did the girls get a promise of equal treatment and equal financing of sports with the guys, Congress even felt it necessary to clarify the Supreme Court's clarifications by passing Title IX, aka the "males and females are exactly alike" statutes.

We are probably going to see much of the same thing after McDonald. The High Court decided that the right to keep and bear arms is an individual right enforceable against the states and municipalities as well as the federal government. So far, so good. The majority justices rejected dissenting Justice Breyer's argument that "there is no popular consensus that the right is fundamental." The majority held that "we have never held that a provision of the Bill of Rights applies to the States only if there is a 'popular consensus,' and we see no basis for such a rule."

In another odd twist of liberal logic, Breyer (this time joined in dissent by Justice Stevens) opined that "the Court should not interfere in this particular area of state versus federal government relationship." This comes from the same justices who have time and again written decisions in which "federalism" always means "complete control of the legal field by the central government in D.C." The majority's counter-argument was straightforward and clear: "Incorporation of the Second Amendment right will to some extent limit the legislative freedom of the States, but this is always true when a Bill of Rights provision is incorporated. Incorporation always restricts experimentation and local variations, but that has not stopped the Court from incorporating virtually every other provision of the Bill of Rights." Yet liberal jurists can find, without much effort, that the Constitution protects homosexual marriage, but can't see that a fully expressed right such as the Second Amendment should apply universally.

Justice Stevens went so far as to say "the relationship between the Bill of Rights' guarantees and the States must be governed by a single, neutral principle." Uh, yeah. And that's exactly what this decision appears to do. It doesn't create some new mystical right found in a constitutional umbra, penumbra or emanation. It merely says that one of the ten basic rights specifically announced by the Founders and applied to the states after the Civil War is so basic as to require enforcement at all levels of government.

OK, so how could I find fault with any of that? For the same reason that Clarence Thomas is my favorite justice. We got where we conservative gun owners wanted to be, didn't we? But did we get there the right way? Thomas thinks not, and again I agree with him. Four of the five justices found that the Fourteenth Amendment required incorporation of the Second Amendment for the states as well as the federal government on the basis of the Due Process Clause. Justice Thomas (and I) respectfully disagree. In his opinion concurring with the majority result, Justice Thomas again pressed the issue of incorporation based on the Privileges and Immunities Clause rather than Due Process.

Until the Warren Court made mincemeat of the words, "due process" meant the same thing it had meant to the Founders, which is to say "procedural due process." Every poor, black, rural nonentity was guaranteed that the courts would treat him in exactly the same way they would treat a rich, white, urban power broker. The Warren Court took the obscure and rarely previously used "substantive due process" concept and made it the order of the day. As opposed to using clear wording and clear intent as it actually exists in the Constitution, it now became the duty of justices to find ways to guarantee the "right" outcome based not on law and precedent, but on their own personal opinions of what the Constitution should have said.

Under Thomas's reasoning, any clear right that is guaranteed by the Constitution and applicable to the federal government must also be incorporated for the states in order to protect the privileges and immunities of every citizen equally. Group rights and "how things ought to be" don't enter into the formula the way substantive due process opinions do. If a citizen of Washington DC enjoys the right to own his own gun because of the Second Amendment (Heller), then a citizen of the municipality of Chicago, state of Illinois must enjoy those same privileges and immunities (McDonald).

It was the time and the opportunity to overturn the findings in the Slaughterhouse Cases of the late 1800s, restore the full and clear meaning of the privileges and immunities clause, and undo the damage done by the activist judicial supremacy advocates using substantive due process as their excuse to legislate from the bench. Those of us who advocate this plan of restoration are very vocal and very determined, but we are also still a small minority in the legal community, as evidenced by the four conservative justices who still found it necessary to incorporate the Second Amendment via the Fourteenth using due process as the basis rather than privileges and immunities.

On the less weighty side of the decision, I also feel I should point out that Obama appointee Sonia Sotomayor, as one of the dissenting justices, turned out to be both the legal ignoramus and liar that many of us warned she would be. During her confirmation hearings, she responded to a direct question on the subject by stating that she believed that Heller established once and for all that gun ownership was a fundamental right guaranteed to individuals, not just to groups (such as militias). But she joined in the dissent which said "I can find nothing in the Second Amendment's text, history, or underlying rationale to protect the keeping and bearing arms for private self-defense purposes."

Aside from the fact that those words are just plain wrong, there is the minor matter of the fact that "self-defense" is only one of the reasons for the guarantee--the major other reason being the right of the citizen to oppose by force of arms an oppressive government. The minority, including Sotomayor, dissented largely by stating that rather than limit the discussion simply to whether Heller should be extended to the states, Heller should just be overturned. I hope our conservative Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee keep that in mind while vetting Elena Kagan during her confirmation hearings. Kagan wonders whether the military should have guns--imagine what she thinks about individuals having that right.
[+] Read More...

Thursday, July 1, 2010

Oops

This time the "oops, I did it again" award goes not to Britney Spears, but to Markos Moulitsas, founder of the Daily Kos. And like Britney, the announcement of the big goof came from Kos himself, although not in the form of a song. More like "you're not gonna believe the really dumb thing I did."

Several of the online conservative newsletters caught this mea culpa at the Daily Kos. I must admit that there are several liberal websites that I visit on a nearly daily basis to see what they're up to. But the Daily Kos and the Huff Po are so lefty-loony and filled with obscenities that I find it hard to stomach them more than a couple of times a month. Thanks to the other bloggers, I was informed of this one at the Daily Kos.

In order to appear to be a legitimate political news and opinion site, the Daily Kos has included regular political polls. Moulitsas relied on Research 2000 for its polls. And here's the hot news from the Kos himself: "I have just published a report by three statistics wizards showing, quite convincingly, that the weekly Research 2000 State of the Nation poll we ran the past year and a half was likely bunk. While the investigation didn't look at all of Research 2000 polling conducted for us, fact is I no longer have any confidence in any of it, and neither should anyone else (emphasis in original)."

The Research 2000 polls consistently produced results which were favorable to Democrats. In fact, they were "best case of every conceivable best case" favorable to Democrats, particularly progressives. As the Kos put it: "There was reason to be skeptical, but it had nothing to do with ideology." If you rely on polls that always favor your candidates, heavily, I find it hard to believe that ideology had nothing to do with it, Mr. Moulitsas. But indeed that wasn't all of it.

Part of the problem was Kos's benign disregard for favorable results that were believable enough, or semi-believable, even though most other major and respected polls were coming up with different numbers. When a poll consistently disagrees with one conducted where the opposition is somewhat overrepresented, it's understandable that you might want to believe your pollsters. But when Democrat-leaning polls like Gallup consistently show results radically different from those of your pollster, it should be sending up an early warning flag that something might be wrong.

The first example of Kos's naive reliance on Research 2000 was when all the polls were showing that large numbers of Democrats were planning on voting for Republican Scott Brown in Massachusetts for the Ted Kennedy Senate vacancy. But Kos's pollster showed that almost no Democrats were willing to vote for Brown. Even the most hostile of Democratic-leaning polls were showing a substantial number of Democrats straying to Brown's candidacy.

When Research 2000 got the Virginia gubernatorial election, the New Jersey gubernatorial election and the Brown election wildly wrong, only then did Kos decide that he might wish to re-evalute his use of that pollster. More recently, Research 2000 got the numbers very wrong in the Arkansas Democratic Senate primary. Once again, the poll heavily favored the most liberal/progressive candidate, which turned out to be very different from the ultimate first round result. Research 2000/Daily Kos had the numbers at 48% for the more liberal Halter, 46% for Blanche Lincoln and 3% for the conservative D. C. Morrison. In reality, Lincoln had 44.5%, Halter 42.5% and Morrison 13%. The final results were statistically insignificantly different from all the other major polls. Only Research 2000 got it this wrong, at least according to Moulitsas.

And where there's dissension, there's lawyers. Kos's disavowal of Research 2000 was so strong and so unequivocal that the legal vultures are already circling. Kos says he'll sue Research 2000 for failing to perform properly on his agreement with them, while Research 2000 is already making noises about a defamation suit. Kos seems to have forgotten that he's pretty much entitled to say anything he wants about politics and/or politicians in the public eye, but in this case he's directly and very publicly challenging the veracity and competence of a private company with which he was doing business, and alleging what amounts to fraud.

Interestingly, had Moulitsas made all the same allegations in a lawsuit before airing them on his website, he would very likely have been protected by the legal privilege accorded to formally filed lawsuits and the reporter's privilege of reporting on the progress of court cases. I can only say to Moulitsas that he had better turn out to be completely right in his accusations of gross incompetence or dishonesty on the part of Research 2000. Says the attorney for Research 2000 and its CEO, Del Ali: "This guy is completely all wet. The allegation of fraud is absurd. These guys are basically ruining Mr. Ali's business." The attorney also said that on top of everything else, Kos hasn't even paid "the $50, $60, $70,000 that he owes on his bill." Kos, of course, denied this at first, but now seems to be saying "they don't deserve to get paid."

Many of the writers who caught this flap early contend that there's a good chance that Kos knew very early on that the poll numbers were being purposely or negligently skewed. Once it became patently apparent to everyone, they say, that Research 2000 was wildly off-mark on nearly every race, Kos needed to distance himself from his own folly. If true, that late panic on his part may cost him dearly for going off on the pollsters publicly instead of filing a lawsuit first.

One thing more that bothers me about the whole thing. If Moulitsas actually succeeds in winning a fraud action against Research 2000, two questions arise in my mind. The first is why he would rely on the polling skills, data and expertise of a polling company that operates out of a Kinko's office. And as part of that question, has he never heard of the doctrine of caveat emptor (let the buyer beware)? The location and quality of Research 2000's offices might have been a first clue.

Second, if Research 2000 really is that much of a shoestring operation, how does Kos expect to collect the massive money damages he will undoubtedly be demanding in his lawsuit? All in all, it just seems to me that behind the vicious blogging and verbal obscenities of the Daily Kos, emperor Moulitsas may just have no clothes.
[+] Read More...

How To Understand The Public

By now most of you probably heard about the "disaster" at the Daily Kos. It turns out their polling company, Research 2000, has been faking their polling data. **snicker snicker** This has, of course, called into question the validity of all the “analysis” they’ve done over the past. . . well, forever. But their loss is our indifference because liberals believing wrong things is as normal a part of life as breathing. But that raises the question, how do we know what the public is really thinking?

The most obvious answer remains polls: polls can be accurate enough to give you a fair impression of the public’s mood. However, we must always remember that polls suffer from serious limitations. For example, polling relies on obtaining a representative sample. That means they need to poll a large enough group to be able to make certain statistical assumptions, and that group must match the broader population.

And that’s really where the first problems appear. How many Democrats should you include in a poll? How many Republicans? Can you be sure that your independents represent actual independents? It is the answers to these questions that cause poll results to vary so much, even if they all used the same questions. But that’s yet another problem: they don’t ask the same questions, and depending on how the questions are phrases, which words are used, and even the available answers, it is possible to manipulate a poll to such a degree that it no longer represents the public.

But there’s another aspect to polling that needs to be considered: the lack of commitment or intensity. And by this, I mean that people will say things but won’t really mean them. The best example of this comes from environmental polls. “Should we try to stop global warming?” A large percentage of people will answer “yes” to this. So we all believe in global warming and we support cap and trade right? Not quite. When they asked “are you willing to spend $100 a year to stop global warming,” the “yes” numbers crashed. By the same token, if you ask “which of the following candidates would you support in 2012?” and then you list ten candidates, it’s possible that all ten candidates will score 90% approval ratings. But does that actually tell us anything? It really doesn’t because there is no ability to distinguish the intensity or the level of commitment.

The same applies in other areas as well: “Are you so angry at Hollywood that you intend to boycott all future movies?” A sizeable percentage of people will answer “yes” to this. But there’s no way to tell if they are serious. In fact, this question is a very easy way to voice displeasure without undertaking the commitment of following through.

So how do we really know what the public is thinking? You follow behavior and you look for patterns in it. For example, the public says they love candidate X, but is anyone giving them time or money? Are they drawing a disproportionately larger share of money or volunteers than other campaigns? Do they draw larger crowds at events?

It’s the same thing with movies. You see a series of trade publications giving all kinds of awards to actor Y. He’s voted the sexiest man alive, and is cast in dozens of films. The headlines scream -- “everybody loves Y.” But do the box office figures concur? Whether or not people will spend money to see him is what counts. A recent example that demonstrates the importance of following the money is the movie Snakes on a Plane. This turdburger was hyped all over the internet and easily won the “most clicks” war for several weeks before the film came out. But clicks are free, admission isn’t. The movie tanked. Once again, there was a difference between what people said (clicks) and what they did (pay for a ticket).

When I write articles about the public accepting one thing or rejecting another, these are the things I look for. Did the movie make money? Can the movie star sell tickets? Does candidate X actually engender monetary support or just “clicks.” Does the public actually support the actual regulations that will affect them, or just the principle of a happier world?

You can even use anecdotal evidence if you are careful about it. What you need to look for are inconsistencies. For example, the fact that your neighbor complains about Obama means nothing. If they’re conservative, then this is to be expected. If they’re liberal, then it could just be blowing off steam. But a non-political neighbor who expresses anger at something they wouldn’t normally know anything about, can be informative. It can tell you, for example, that what Obama has done has drifted down into the public consciousness and not in a good way. That’s how it first became obvious that the BP spill was a problem for Obama -- people who don’t pay attention to politics were suddenly talking about his response.

Moreover, you can look at how the left reacts. For example, the more shrill the denials that a particular event has any meaning, the greater the likelihood that it actually has struck a chord and they are worried. This is what confirmed that the public was upset about the BP spill, because leftists were falling all over themselves to write articles telling us that no one cared.

This is also how I can tell you that financial reform means nothing to the public. First, note the lack of articles about financial reform. That’s because journalists aren’t going to write about something the public doesn’t care about. Secondly, note that when we write about it, the numbers of comments drop dramatically and the comments themselves become very short. This isn’t a lack of brainpower on the part of readers, it’s a lack of interest. Add in the falling ratings of the business news channels and the disappearance of business news from newspapers and nightly news shows, and what you get is the public voting with their feet, i.e. they are changing the channel because they don’t care.

Further, you can often derive fascinating information about the public from the strangest sources. Indeed, one of the most brilliant strategists the Republicans ever had, the late Lee Atwater, once said that he would read the National Enquirer every day. The reason was that this newspaper of made up news told him what the American public was thinking about.

Examples of the kinds of things I’m talking about here could include (1) the lack of success of energy efficient products, which indicates that consumers aren’t willing to substitute environmentalism for quality; (2) the lack of success of recent Megan Fox films, which could signal public anger at her insulting political statements; (3) surges in gun sales and security systems in certain areas, which indicate a loss of confidence in the local police; or (4) consumer spending going down even as consumer confidence polls are going up.

And you can also get to what the public really values in this way. For example, a few months back, there was an interesting tidbit from Netflix. People keep serious movies significantly longer than the mindless stuff. The reason, it turns out, is that people rent the serious stuff because “they should,” but then never want to watch it. In fact, many of these films are kept for several weeks before being returned unwatched. What does this tell us? It tells us that despite protestations that the public likes “deep” and “serious” entertainment, it actually prefers the mindless stuff. How is that useful knowledge? Well, it helps you understand the psyche of the public -- the public has an idea of what they should be like, but they don’t live up to that. So if you are planning a political campaign, this tells you not to make it hard on them. This also tells us to remember that the public may over-idealize itself in response to polls.

There are millions of more examples, but this should give you a sense of the kinds of places you can look to see what the public really believes. Polls are nice, but it’s actions that matter. And within actions, there are patterns and motivations.

To understand the public, consider the old saying turned around: “do as I do, not as I say.”

[+] Read More...