It is so hot here in NYC that you could probably fry an egg right on the sidewalk. As a matter of fact, I had to escape to the cool breezes of South Texas last week just to get away from this oven. But the heat is not the only news...
Sports: It has been a sad week for baseball and especially for the New York Yankees. On July 11, Bob Sheppard, long time Yankee announcer known as the Yankee's "Voice of God" passed away at the age of 99. He announced the play by play for all the home games from 1951 to 2007. For you baseball buffs, the first game he called in 1951 against the Boston Red Sox included baseball legends Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle, Johnny Mize, Yogi Berra, Phil Rizzuto and Bosox great Ted Williams.
Sadly, Mr. Sheppard was joined two days later by George Steinbrenner, long time owner of the Yankees who died suddenly of a heart attack at age 80. Steinbrenner built the Yankees into a winning-est team in baseball (while at the same time repeatedly firing and rehiring legendary manager Billy Martin) in the 37 years as owner. He had recently turned over the everyday operations to his son. Both of these great men will be missed.
Local: So, a few week ago I reported that the MTA was going to cut my bus line, but some free-enterprising young man with a small bus company was going to pick up the route privately for the same fare and everything. I think my exact words were "Take that you, Marxist scum". Well, this industrious young man did take over the bus route and, just as we were working out the kinks and barely two weeks in service, the City Legal Department filed an injunction to shut the operation down and with no real explanation as to why. The New York Daily News reported that the Transit workers' union was not happy that someone would get paid to drive a bus and they wouldn't get a cut of the action. A hearing was held this week on the injunction, but to my knowledege, the judge did not make any final decision on the fate of this new little busline. But, at this point, it really doesn't matter. Even if the judge were to rule for the bus line owner, the damage has already been done. The young entrepeneur's opportunity to slide right in and expand his business, hire additional employees, and with an already willing customer base has all but slipped away. The delay and uncertainty in service has already forced the would-be riders to make other, more concrete arrangements and are much less likely to want to change back. Once again, the small businessman is denied an opportunity because of stupid, short-sighted Government bureaucrats in cahoots with Big Union thugs.
Terrorist Updates - In November 2009, I reported about Lynne Stewart, former Civil Rights Defense attorney who was convicted of conspiracy for helping her client Egyptian cleric Sheikh Omar Abdel-Rahman, had just lost her appeal and had been immediately remanded into the care of our state Penal system to await final disposition. The Appeals Court had upheld her conviction, but sent the case back down to the sentencing judge for reconsideration because they felt his original sentence of 28 months was too lenient for such a serious crime amongst other considerations. Well, this week the judge finally weilded that hammer of justice and sentenced Ms. Stewart to a hefty 10 years in prison. He attributed her arrogance and unrepentent attitude about her earlier sentence (for which she told the judge that she could do the time "standing on her head") to his new, much harsher decision. Needless to say she was shocked by her sudden change of fortune and threw herself on the mercy of the court boo-hooing that she was just too old to be in prison and wouldn't survive. The judge was unmoved and, well, the air in NYC got a little bit sweeter...
In other terrorist news - Protests continue around the proposed building of "Cordoba House", a new Islamic Cultural Center to be built two blocks from Ground Zero. Daisy Khan, executive director of the American Society of Muslim Advancement along with her husband, Feisel Abdul Rauf made an offer on a 100+ year old building damaged on 9/11 that they want to convert to a cultural outreach center where all will be welcomed and swear on a stack of Korans that it will not be a mosque. In May, they passed one of many hurdles by winning a ringing endorsement for the very liberal local Community Board. This week they presented their case to the Historical Preservation Board which has been stalling for years on an application to give the former coat factory building historical status. Depending on which way the Board decides, this could possibly be the last hurdle the Khan-Raufs have before they can actually become the owners of the property. Everyone waits with bated breath for the Board to render its decision and, as you can imagine, many people in NYC are upset by the prospect of an Islamic anything just 200 feet from the WTC site.
And finally in State related news - Governor Patterson has been furiously vetoing 6000+ new bills that our worthless Legislature passed right before the summer break and against all common sense. Patterson stated that "...[r]ather than act in the interests of the people of New York state, they have engaged in legislation that is in self-interest and presented us with a series of bills that have the same gimmicks, chicanery and avoidant conduct that has characterized fiscal management in this state for far too long." He is making good on his promise to veto any bill that did not reduce the budget. And now he has until the middle of August to complete the veto process which includes reading and signing each and every bill personally. This job is made doubly difficult since Patterson is also legally blind, but he determined he will complete his task. As of July 4th weekend, I believe he was about a quarter of the way through. I can't wait to see what the Legislature will do next since who knows which legislator will be sent to prison next, but that is for the next installment.
[+] Read More...
Saturday, July 17, 2010
New York State of Mind
University Officials Act Like Kindergarteners
Just when I think academic idiocy, political correctness, and group-victimology can't get any sillier or more destructive to free thinking, they do. The University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign has relieved a professor of his duties for teaching the Catholic view on homosexuality, in a course on Catholic teaching. Well--what can we expect from a University system which would hire Obama buddy William Ayers?Dr. Kenneth Howell may or may not subscribe to the Catholic teaching on homosexuality, and to his credit has never expressed his personal view on the matter. But he was paid by the university to teach about Catholic doctrine, and it would have been academically dishonest of him to lie about Catholic teaching on homosexuality. And an issue so much in front of the public certainly couldn't be ignored in a university course about Catholicism either. So without making judgments or expressing his approval or disapproval, the professor proceeded to state the doctrinal facts.
In an e-mail to all his students expanding on the theme, again expressing neither approval nor disapproval, Howell restated the Catholic position in response to a student question. One student apparently was asleep or listening to his I-Pod during the in-class lecture, so when he got the e-mail he was so stricken with horror, fear and loathing that he immediately reported the professor to school officials. Says this young budding academic genius: "Allowing this hate speech at a public university is entirely unacceptable." Hate speech my arse. I'm assuming he hasn't yet taken the uncensored course on Islam.
Howell wasn't even solely discussing, and therefore wasn't specifically emphasizing, the Catholic view. He had been asked to compare the utilitarian and natural moral law views on homosexuality as they relate to Catholic doctrine. That is a very intelligent question which calls for careful analysis and discussion, which Dr. Howell provided. But it may also have been a setup. Perhaps the ultrasensitive homosexuals and their supporters didn't have enough hard evidence against this horrible homophobe and simply wanted some kind of documentation. On the other hand, it could just be that a really stupid student missed the lecture and didn't know his tender lily soul had been attacked until he read the e-mail. Who knows? Who cares?
Ya know, when you sign up for a course on natural fertilizer, you should be prepared for someone to talk shit. And when you sign up for a course on Catholicism, you should be prepared to hear a viewpoint on homosexuality that differs from those of your fellow liberals. You should also be prepared to accept the concept that giving the facts about a viewpoint is hardly the same thing as advocating that viewpoint. But try to explain that to college students who have heard only the left wing revisionist version of pretty much everything their entire lives.
Where Howell went wrong was in actually presenting an adult, intelligent, serious, and accurate description of one point of debate among the utilitarians and natural moral law advocates. But these students are used to nothing more complicated or intellectually challenging than professorial grunts such as "Marxism good, capitalism bad." Natural moral law, properly analyzed, says that morality must be a response to reality. "In other words, sexual acts are only appropriate for people who are complementary, not the same. How do we know this? By looking at reality. Men and women are complementary in their anatomy, physiology, and psychology. Men and women are not interchangeable. So, a moral sexual act has to be between persons who are fitted for that final act."
That is not an expression of Howell's opinion (though outside the academic arena he may or may not agree with it). It is an entirely accurate description of natural moral law as announced by the Catholic Church. How refreshing to have a professor who can intelligently discuss an actual point of view held by millions (billions?) of people and most religious institutions in direct answer to a question posed without adding his own editorial comments on the truth or falsity of the position.
Catholic doctrine and natural moral law also posit that there must be a connection between sex and procreation. Is that my opinion? Is that Dr. Howell's opinion? What difference does it make in an academic setting? It's an accurate description of Catholic doctrine, the course is about Catholic doctrine, and the question posed was about Catholic doctrine. For once, we actually have a professor who simply gives an accurate answer rather than a predigested opinion of a subject that he may or may not agree with.
University president Michael Hogan responded to inquiries about the dismissal with the usual academic gobbledygook about academic freedom and the free exchange of ideas. In other words, he did the exact opposite of what professor Howell did. He dodged the question and left nobody knowing more after his speechifying baloney than they did before it. He also paraphrased the UI Handbook, which says: "Academic freedom is essential to the functioning of a university. It applies to its teaching, research, and public service and involves both faculty and students."
Of course he neglected to mention that the professor who is now not allowed to teach anything at UI had received the plaudits of his students and an academic award from the faculty and administration for teaching exactly the same subject in exactly the same way just the previous semester. The most effusive words of praise for Howell had come from the entire faculty of the UI Department of Religion.
These tender reeds who can't survive the statement of facts without opinion should all be kicked out on their sensitive butts and the professor should be reinstated immediately with an open public apology from all the cowards and bullies involved in his dismissal. I'm not holding my breath for that. However, the Alliance Defense Fund has already sent a demand letter to the school demanding reinstatement for professor Howell no later than July 16 (yesterday, by the time of this publication) or face a lawsuit. The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education has also indicated an interest in the matter, but has made no formal statement or taken any action thus far.
I am alternately annoyed and infuriated by liberals who can't get it through their heads that there are actually people who don't hold the same point of view. But even that's not the issue here. Howell didn't state either his view or his opinion. He gave a yeoman's answer to a direct question about a subject that he was hired to teach openly, honestly and accurately. Try to get that out of a lefty professor. These nervous nellies who go to the university to have their own opinions validated are going to be the death of genuine university learning. University administrators who act on these complaints from silly students with heads full of Jell-O without even considering that a dismissal of a highly qualified professor could be seriously injurious to academic freedom and solid thought should be tossed out along with the students too weak to handle the truth.
[+] Read More...
Friday, July 16, 2010
Barbara Boxer Goes Off The Rails--Again
One very important issue in the matchup between incumbent Senator "Her Majesty" Barbara Boxer and Republican candidate Carly Fiorina will be one that didn't play a big part in the primaries. The Republican primary candidates ranged from moderate to absolutist on the issue of abortion, with Fiorina in the moderate camp. It's one reason I voted for a different candidate.But the issue becomes a different one in the general election. Boxer is among the most adamant pro-abortionists in the Senate, while Fiorina, who is moderate about "choice," is a hawk on forbidding federal funding of abortions. That is a principled position, even though I think moderation in relation to abortion is a moral mistake. Still, it means that Fiorina is taking a stand in favor of a "woman's right to choose" (bad), but neither encourages abortion nor wishes to have antiabortion taxpayers foot the bill (good). I've lived in this State and its liberal environment long enough to think that on this issue, Fiorina is about as good as we're going to get.
The illustration is a representation of an eight week old baby in the womb. Abortion advocates call that a "thing," a "problem to be dealt with," a "fetus," or "that mistake." I'm just a simpleton, so what I see is a small, helpless, innocent human being. Fiorina isn't sure what she sees, but at least she doesn't want to kill it, or have us pay for its death. Boxer, of course, sees the rotten little troublemaker who is going to send innocent women into deadly back alleys for their abortions and the source of imprisonment for conscientious doctors who are only trying to help.
Boxer is not your ordinary run-of-the-mill abortion supporter. She absolutely exalts in it. But she's facing a California electorate that only recently rejected a ballot measure which would have required that underage pregnant girls to inform their parents that they are considering having an abortion. So this isn't as simple for Fiorina as it might seem on its face. Boxer once faced Pennsylvania Senator Rick Santorum in a Senate abortion debate. He pushed and pushed, and then pushed some more to get Boxer to state at which point a baby becomes a human being with rights.
Boxer waffled, dodged and obfuscated. But Santorum kept pushing. Finally, probably out of exhaustion and failure to deflect the question by calling it unfair, Boxer answered. "I think when you bring your baby home, when your baby is born, the baby belongs to your family and has rights." Thanks, Babs. And before then, while you're still at the hospital, I assume it's not a human being, so you can just toss it into the medical waste container. "Reprehensible" is far too mild a word to describe your viewpoint. And at least in the past, California voters seemed to find that to be a perfectly reasonable position.
Although I deeply disagree with the law, science and moral philosophy inherent in the original version of Roe v Wade, I can at least recognize that at a very early stage of pregnancy, there is a difference of opinion even among antiabortion folks about when life actually begins. There are also those of us who are reluctantly willing to make early term exceptions for incest, rape or the physical survival of the mother. But those are areas of genuine, thoughtful and theological disagreement.
Boxer, on the other hand, supports both partial-birth abortion and funding of partial-birth abortion. In the debate with Santorum, he kept asking her "if X part of the baby still remains inside the mother's body, should it still be morally and legally acceptable to kill the baby so long as it hasn't completely emerged?" Boxer dodged that question on multiple occasions by deflecting the question with indignant charges that Santorum was "losing his temper." But she finally had to capitulate and answer the question. As far as I'm concerned, her answer not only disqualified her from being in the Senate, but disqualifies her from being a member of decent society.
Her position is even clearer than that of Hillary Clinton at around the same time. Clinton was asked, "if the abortion is scheduled at noon, but the baby is born in the elevator on the way to the abortion table at 11:50 AM, should it be legal to allow the baby to die, since the legal decision had already been made to terminate the pregnancy?" Unlike Boxer, Clinton actually had to consider the question for a moment before giving an answer that ignored the issue entirely. Boxer's answer probably would have been "of course--just toss it down the elevator shaft."
Boxer has already tested the waters on abortion by tossing out the usual attack on Fiorina's modest pro-life stance. "She wants to make abortion a crime, and that would mean women and doctors in jail." Fiorina didn't waffle or shrink from the attempted attack. "That's a ridiculous statement. I happen to believe in the sanctity of life, but the great majority of Californians disagree with Barbara Boxer, who believes that taxpayers should be funding partial-birth abortion."
Wherever Fiorina stands on early and mid-term abortion, she's very clear on late-term. She abhors it, and will fight to keep it from being funded by the taxpayers. If she continues to use the real words "partial-birth abortion," and continues to explain her opposition to the homicide of a fully viable tiny human being, she could very well bring along even the pro-choicers. At least those pro-choicers who aren't cold-blooded baby haters like, say, Barbara Boxer.
[+] Read More...
Newsvertising
A lot of people talk about the blurring between news and entertainment. That’s certainly a problem because it’s led to the dumbing down of the news to a point where you need attention deficit disorder just to watch it. But I’m more concerned about the blurring of news and advertising. I see this as a very serious problem.I first noticed this phenomenon when a free subscription to Entertainment Weekly appeared in my mailbox. Not only was this turd of a “magazine” written at the first grade level, but it didn’t take long to realize that this “magazine” was nothing more than one giant ad for the movie industry. Page after page were “stories” whose sole purpose was to get me to go see various films. Even when they panned a film, they still somehow managed to suggest that I see it. . . just not in the first week.
Soon I realized that the entertainment “news” presented on the nightly news was no different. The days of a reviewer cautioning you to avoid a lousy film were gone. In their place were pretty boys and ditzy girls who showed you promotional clips and gushed about every film; they even developed ways to sell the bad ones. . . “so bad it’s good.” And when they weren’t selling the movie directly, they did stories hyping these films as “events,” and encouraging you to take part in the “excitement” leading up the film. Basically, they ceased being reporters and became salespeople.
Then they added “gossip.” But there’s something you need to know about this gossip: most of it is manufactured to promote a film. It’s no coincidence that you will see a “random” story about Actor X’s new house or some “funny moment” Actor X had at a night club, the week before Actor X’s new film hits the screen. This is all intended to create a buzz. . . which will, of course, lead to stories about the buzz. That's called marketing, not reporting.
Then Hollywood hit upon a brilliant stroke. You know those interviews where some reporter sits down with Actor X to "discuss" their new film? Do you know how those are done? It's not actually a one on one experience. Instead, a slew of reporters show up to a pre-set location. Actor X sits in front of a blue screen as each reporter is cycled through. Each reporter is usually allowed only a couple questions, so they know to stay on script. And what's really key is that the actor will pretend to know the reporter. Thus, each reporter gets to look like they are “players” in Hollywood because their viewers think they managed to finagle an interview with a busy actor that they know personally. In exchange, the studio gets a couple hundred free ads on the local and national news. This is a quid pro quo, and reporters aren’t supposed to do that.
And it’s not just Hollywood. Sports “news” also has entered the pimping world. For generations, sports news meant providing a box score, a quick description of the key moments in the game, and a few quotes from one side or the other. No longer. First, they added highlights, which is understandable as television is a visual medium. But then they started adding “top ten hits of the week” and other segments that look an awful lot like advertisements for the league.
Then the NFL hit upon a great idea: use the promise of access to control the media. In exchange for locker room access and press access to Super Bowl week, the NFL began telling the media what they could or could not report. This included, for example, removing the journalistic “credentials” of people who criticized the NFL, and it included limits on what kinds of videos the media could use and for how long they could use them (nothing longer than 45 seconds and must be removed from websites in 24 hours). The media caved without even a whimper. Soon, the NFL was providing canned “news” stories to the media, which the media dutifully reported without change. Suddenly stories about brain damage resulting from concussions, drug use, arrests and labor unrest disappeared or became dismissive. In their place were NFL-approved stories about “the NFL experience,” the importance of new stadiums to cities, and NFL efforts to make sure that merchandise was high quality. . . usually accompanied with a mention of where you could buy said merchandise.
And lest you think, “well sports and entertainment people really aren’t journalists,” it’s hit the business news as well. CNBC doesn’t send reporters out to uncover news and report upon it. No, they let the "news" come to them. Thus, their programming days are packed with fund managers who come to say something generic about the market as they pimp their funds. They bring in CEOs to talk about new products or their latest books. And they’ve become a vehicle for damage control. Whenever a company gets caught doing something it shouldn’t, you can bet the CEO will appear on CNBC within a couple days to provide a whitewash version of what happened and to tell us about all the great things the company is doing. And don't think the reporters use this moment for a couple of hard-hitting questions. No, they put on well-practiced stern looks and then pitch a few softball questions before concluding: “I’m glad to hear you’re fixing this.” Then they trot out an analyst to tell you that now (or maybe in a week) is the time to buy the company’s stock, right before they cut to commercial, which (purely by “coincidence”) will be a paid ad for the company. Finally, they take the segment highlights and replay them ad nauseum.
Even the “regular” news is slowly giving way to product tie-ins and segments that look like sponsored ads. That story about how hard it is to find certain toys? That was suggested and assisted by the marketing department at ToyCo. That story about which national chain has the best fries or “will Company X’s new product sell”? Ditto. The story about the new healthy menu at Restaurant Z, or the new innovations at Tech Company A? Same thing. The story about the “latest trend” that just happens to tell you what brand you need to buy and where to buy it. . .
In each instance, what you have is a symbiotic relationship between the media and business. Business has learned that it can use the news to advertise its products. It offers ready-made stories and incentives to the media to report these “stories,” and the reporters accept them because it makes their jobs easier. . . just sit back and a script will come to you.
So why does this bother me? Two reasons. First, I want news that I can trust, and that requires an impartial media that seeks out the truth, rather than just passing along marketing-department-created propaganda.
Secondly, I hate sounding like the left, but I am concerned about the effects of this on society. Science has shown that humans are very susceptible to the cumulative effects of advertising; and the effects are much stronger when the advertising comes from a trusted source. I suspect that advertising is largely responsible for driving consumers to the point of bankruptcy, increasing patient demands for drugs, increasing obesity, and a host of other bad behaviors. But as bad as this is, at least with advertisements, people know that Madison Avenue is attempting to brainwash them. That’s no longer true when “the news” starts telling you what to buy and where to buy it. And that is truly insidious.
[+] Read More...
Thursday, July 15, 2010
Obama Finally Upset At Al Qaeda, Over "Racism"
Look out al Qaeda, now you’ve done it. You’ve finally given Obama a justification to wipe you out with extreme prejudice. . . no pun intended. What is it that al Qaeda did? Did they kill Americans? No. Did they kill Christians so they could spread Islam with murderous force? Nope. Did they kill young girls trying to get an education? No. They’re RACISTS!!!For those who don’t know what happened recently, al Qaeda set off a series of bombs in Uganda, killing 74 people. Did Obama suggest careful restraint on the part of the Ugandans? "Don't jump to conclusions?" "Give peace a chance?" No. Instead, Obama finally realized that al Qaeda is evil:
Yes, Mr. President, al Qaeda wants to destroy and kill. What could possibly have finally taught Obama this basic lesson that the other six billion of us already knew? Hmmm. What could it be? If only Obama had said more. . . wait, he did:“It was so tragic and ironic to see an explosion like this take place when people in Africa were celebrating and watching the World Cup take place in South Africa. On the one hand, you have a vision of an Africa on the move, an Africa that is unified, an Africa that is modernizing and creating opportunities; and on the other hand, you've got a vision of al Qaeda and Al Shabaab that is about destruction and death.”
Ah, now I see. Wanting to blow up honkus maximus in New York City? That’s understandable. Wipe out those dirty Jews? Totally justified. Teach old Europe a bloody lesson? Heck, that’s nothing. But seeing African life as not valuable!! What an outrage!!!"What you've seen in some of the statements that have been made by these terrorist organizations is that they do not regard African life as valuable in and of itself. They see it as a potential place where you can carry out ideological battles that kill innocents without regard to long-term consequences for their short-term tactical gains."
And in case you think I might be overstating this, try this on for size. Explaining Obama’s comments, an administration official said the following:
So it’s not the tens of thousands of murders that bother Obama. It’s not the war in Iraq, the war in Afghanistan, or the murder of American soldiers. It’s not the killing, the destruction, the attempt to impose a religion by force, the enslaving of women, or the attempts to wipe out Israel. It’s that al Qaeda has a glass ceiling for Terrorists Of African Descent (TOADS)?“[Mr. Obama] references the fact that both U.S. Intelligence and past al Qaeda actions make clear that al Qaeda -- and the groups like al Shabaab that they inspire -- do not value African life. The actions of al Qaeda and the groups that it has inspired show a willingness to sacrifice innocent African life to reach their targets.
Al Qaeda recruits have said that al Qaeda is racist against black members from West Africa because they are only used in lower level operations. In short, al Qaeda is a racist organization that treats black Africans like cannon fodder and does not value human life.”
WTF?!
Presumably, an NAACP boycott will now follow. And if they don’t start treating TOADS right, then Jesse Jackass will show up at Osama bin Laden’s cave and stage a protest. Maybe Obama will even hold a Falafel summit? Or Eric Holder can bring suit against al Qaeda in federal court to enforce equal rights for TOADS?
Let me explain something to our Dipsh*t in Chief. Sir, al Qaeda hates us all. They don’t care if you are black or white or yellow or purple: if you are an infidel, then you are marked for death. They do not respect you, they do not want an accommodation or to live in peace. They want to kill, that is all they want. The outrage is that they want to kill anyone, not that they want to kill "black Africans." Only a black racist would see that as THE problem.
Obama whines: “They see [Africa] as a potential place where you can carry out ideological battles that kill innocents without regard to long-term consequences for their short-term tactical gains."
Wrong, jackass. They see THE PLANET EARTH as a place where they can carry on an ideological battle. And it’s not “ideological,” it’s religious. And they aren’t engaged in a battle "that kills innocents," they kill innocents -- there is no collateral damage here, it's all intentional. If you don’t understand this, then you are stupider than Joe Biden.
Our readers know that I am not prone to hyperbole. So when I say that this bothers me deeply, I mean it. When I see a President who tells us not to get worked up when Islamic terrorists kill Americans, who tells the Arab world that we are at fault for terrorism, and who can only get himself worked up when Africans are killed, I find that truly despicable.
Moreover, this is not just a single off-the-cuff mistake, it's part of a disturbing pattern: from Michelle's comments about finally being proud of America, to Obama's bizarre repeated insults to Britain (and France and Germany), to his instantaneous accusation of racism in the arrest of a belligerent black professor, to his claims that the Tea Party is racist, to his Justice Department turning a blind eye to the racist Black Panthers who engaged in voter intimidation, to his hiring of open race-haters like Van Jones, to his appointment of a "wise Latina," to his attempts to stoke race-hate in response to the Arizona immigration bill.
Racism is ugly, no matter what race practices it.
You, Mr. Obama, are a disgrace.
[+] Read More...
Index:
AndrewPrice,
Barack Obama,
Race Relations,
Terrorism
Help ! I'm Bound By Law !
That's a picture of my old colleague Tacitus. I think he practiced law in Rome about the same time I was first admitted to the Bar in California. Corruptissima re publica, plurimae leges, said Tacitus. "The more corrupt the government, the more laws it has." Lao Tzu, the teacher of Confucius, said it slightly differently: "The more laws and order are made prominent, the more thieves and robbers there will be."As a man of modern America, I'll put it even more bluntly--there are too damned many laws, too damned many lawyers, and a government growing more corrupt by the day. One of the problems with too many laws is that it creates not only a fertile environment for selective enforcement, but it also includes a great many very silly laws that make little sense, rarely accomplish the alleged goal, and allows lazy police and lazy prosecutors to criminalize those least likely to resist.
The worst of these non-criminal criminal statutes are those commonly called "zero-tolerance" laws (although sometimes they're only the "policies" of governmental agencies). It's one of those concepts that looks good on purpose, and usually produces almost immediately a disastrous result. For example, four kindergartners were playing cops and robbers at Wilson Elementary in New Jersey. It was the usual bloody stuff. Bang, bang, you're dead. But one of the kids got creative and yelled "Boom! I have a bazooka, and I'm going to shoot you." Now I'm sure you can guess that a five year old at school didn't really have a bazooka. No matter.
The four kids were hauled off and suspended from school for three days for making threats. The school administrators not only have a zero-tolerance policy for weapons on campus, they also have a zero-tolerance policy toward any kid who pretends he has a weapon, and threatens to use the nonexistent ordnance. Puffing himself up to his full superintendent self-important height, William Bauer announced: "This is a no-tolerance policy. We're very firm on weapons and threats." He was backing up the even dumber statement of principal Georgia Bauer who had said: "We cannot take any of these statements in a light manner." Of course you can, you dipstick. Kids. Imaginary weapons. Play threats. What drugs are you people on?
I can understand the reasoning, however. It's very important to get those violent, imaginary bazooka-toting kindergarteners out of the way as quickly as possible. If they weren't removed, they might distract the rest of the students from the more important purposes of kindergarten life--such as the study of graphic sex (think I'm making that up? Check out the latest flap in the Montana schools).
John Stossel did a very good analysis of the underlying problem. Most of these "laws" are being enforced by bureaucrats with absolutely no understanding of law, justice, mercy, tolerance, and plain damned common sense. The usual response to criticism of enforcing this nonsense is "well, it's a rule, and rules must apply to everyone." Yeah. Even if it makes no sense, and the claimed offense has nothing to do with the intent of the rule. The rule was designed to protect helpless children from armed criminals showing up on campus with the intent to do harm. Try explaining that to a low-level functionary in a bureaucracy who only knows "a rule is a rule."
How about another example? Lindsay Brown was a pitch-perfect student and citizen at her high school. In 2001, Lindsay parked her car in a parking place where students weren't allowed to part. Now you think that I'm going to tell you the bureaucrat unfairly gave her a ticket for illegal parking. You would be wrong. Not satisfied with the pinnacle of success in his little life of finding a scofflaw parker, the highly-trained officer of the law peered inside the vehicle. And what did he find? An atomic bomb? A stash of weapons-grade anthrax? A cruise missile? Nope. He spotted a round-tipped butter knife. In an excess of personal bravery, the county mountie didn't call in Homeland Security, the FBI, the bomb squad, or the National Guard. Instead, at great personal risk, he arrested Lindsay on a felony weapons charge. This is going to sound familiar. When asked why he did it, this Keystone Kop replied: "A weapon is a weapon." He forgot to add "But a good cigar is a smoke."
I'll bet you didn't know that there are laws against the importation of undersized lobster tails. Well, now you know. Stossel tells the story of a bureaucrat at the National Marine Fishery Service who was lucky enough to receive an anonymous fax indicating that exporter David McNab was shipping undersized lobster tails into Alabama from Honduras. Aha! The crime of the century! So our NMFS Eliot Ness rushed to the site of the latest lobster tail delivery. In a $4 million shipment of lobster tails (that's a LOT of lobster tails), several were actually found to be undersized. But the J. Edgar Hoovers of the NMFS found an even more horrifying act of criminality.
The lobster tails were packaged in clear plastic bags. The agency knew for a certainty that Honduran law required that they be packaged solely in a prescribed type of cardboard box. Horrors! The shipment was seized, and McNab served eight years in a federal prison, even though the Honduran government informed the saviors of civilization that the regulation requiring cardboard boxes had been repealed.
We're getting closer to rule of the mindless bureaucrats like Europe all the time. They even tell you how long a legal banana is. The EU has big holdings in Africa, where they grow short bananas. The US has most of its investment in Central and South America, which produce larger, longer bananas. So, in Europe, legal bananas are conveniently shorter than illegal bananas from South and Central America. No issue of quality, taste or safety, just "smaller is better." I'm told that the EU is considering eliminating this silly rule, but I'm still waiting for the US to get rid of the Spanish-American War excise tax on telephone usage.
The list goes on. 12 year old arrested, handcuffed and taken to juvenile hall for eating a French fry in a DC Metrorail station. Asked why, in a city that is one of the murder capitals of the world, the chief of Metro Transit Police replied "We really do believe in zero-tolerance." In other words, it's illegal to bring food onto the platforms, the girl finished a French fry she had started eating before entering the platform, and, as we all know by now, "rules are rules." Just for safety's sake, he added" "Anyone taken into custody has to be handcuffed for officer safety." I can understand that. The girl might have had a hidden French fry that she could stab the officer with. The law has since been repealed.
At the University of Notre Dame, there was a double-whammy arrest which carried out both the desires of bureaucrats and First Amendment haters. Student Keith Sampson was researching the Ku Klux Klan. One day in the school library, he was reading "Notre Dame versus the Klan: How the Fighting Irish Defeated the Ku Klux Klan." So far, so good. But, terror of terrors, the book had a cover depicting the Klan. One of the sensitive nearby students who could look at pictures but apparently can't read reported Sampson for racial harassment.
Sampson was suspended, faced expulsion, and perhaps even criminal charges because he made the mistake of reading a book in a university library which was wholly anti-Klan. But oh----that picture on the cover! Asked why the young man was threatened with such drastic action, the university provost replied (do I need to say it?): "Rules are rules, and we have zero tolerance for racial harassment." Lucky for him, FIRE (the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education) took up his cause, and made the whole thing go away, except for the humiliation and fright, of course.
In case you haven't figured it out, there is a socio-political element to these laws, rules and regulations that has next to nothing with protecting the public and preserving the tradition of ordered liberty. Why risk the danger of apprehending a murderer when you can arrest people guilty of offending political-correctness or defying the fad of the day? The murderer has stuck deep at the heart of civilized society, but it's far more important to arrest someone who might be a future litterer, or closet-racist, or WMD-bearer, or even unacceptably obese. Well, after all, rules are rules.
[+] Read More...
Wednesday, July 14, 2010
It's A Progressive Condition, It Won't Get Better...
For some time now, I’ve been pointing out that the left is not happy with Obama. This weekend gave us another huge bit of proof. What proof you ask? An article in the Politico full of the illogical whiny ramblings of various “progressives” who are dismayed at how paradise turned out.The article starts by summing up the problem the left is facing: “For many liberals, this is the summer of their discontent. Already disappointed with Obama’s ability to deliver on campaign promises, they now contemplate a slowing economic recovery and a good chance of Republican gains in November.”
Of course, I would argue that it was Obama’s attempts to deliver on campaign promises that was the real problem, both for the economy and for the new found popularity of the Republicans, but let’s not let facts get in the way of a good whine.
According to the article, this last week saw a sort of dueling banjos thing going on in progressive ranks, with a 17,000 word piece published in The Nation by Eric Alterman and a counterpiece published by Michael Tomasky in Democracy: A Journal of [Lousy] Ideas.
Said wordy Eric, Obama’s presidency is “a big disappointment” for progressives. He blames the system. . . and the boogeyman: “Face it, the system is rigged, and it’s rigged against us.” He even titles this little missive, “Why a progressive presidency is impossible for now.” Aw, poor dear. Apparently, young Eric has realized part of the truth, he just can’t bring himself to understand the real reasons. The system is rigged against them because Americans aren't stupid enough to believe what he believes.
Tomasky takes a different approach than young Eric. He says that it’s too early for progressive to quit: “The changes we want to see won’t happen in 18 months, or in two years, or four, or probably even eight,” and he suggests that the progressive community is still throwing a bit of a tantrum, and nothing will change until they stop.
Katrina vanden Heuvel, the editor of The Nation, tries to blame the existential: “It’s not just really about Obama; it’s about the state of our country. Every day, you have a sense that people are wondering where this country is headed.” And no doubt they crave socialism, right? Delusion is a powerful drug, isn’t it Comradina?
Some blame the stimulus bill which contained “too many compromises in a futile attempt to garner Republican support.” Yep. Of course, those of us who haven’t been snorting liberal pixy dust will remember that the Democrats controlled the House and a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate, so this “evil Republicans stabbed us in the back” thing won’t wash.
Comrade Les Leopold of Firedoglake provides us with the most interesting quote. Let’s take it apart piece by piece:
E.J. Dionne Jr., who is named after a mustard, whines that ObamaCare should have been a victory but turned into a failure. Why? Because it took too long! “It simply took too long to pass health care.” Which I guess tells us that E.J., which stands for Extreme Jerk, has a short, short, short attention span. Because there is no other way to make sense of that quote.• “It’s open season on Obama, whom so many hoped would lead us out of the neoliberal wilderness.” Yeah, I’ve been there, that place sucks, the WhinyCommieBears are really annoying!
• “He once was a community organizer and ought to know how working people have suffered through a generation of tax breaks for the rich.” Huh? How does a tax break for someone else cause me to suffer? Oh that’s right, you live on spite. Sorry, my bad. Please continue. . .
• “When the economy crashed, he was in the perfect position to limit the unjustified pay levels on Wall Street.” So a moron blogger knows what is justified in pay? Dare I suggest that if Comrade Les gets a penny, then his pay is unjustified.
• “Instead, we got a multitrillion-dollar bailout for Wall Street, no health care reform, no serious financial reforms whatsoever, record unemployment and political gridlock that will be with us for years to come.” Hello! You're talking about Democrats! What else did you expect?
But enough about the preliminaries. These are progressives after all, which means they will eventually get around to blaming a cartoon villain. . .
“Whatever the motivation, it has become easier and easier for a determined minority to throw sand in the gears of the legislative process,” says our friend Eric. “It is therefore no coincidence that the 40 Republican senators with the ability to bottle up almost anything in the Senate represent barely a third of the U.S. population.”
Oh Eric, you wrote this just for me didn’t you? For it has not become easier and easier to throw sand in the legislative gears; the rules haven’t changed in decades. Nor, my idiotic young friend, did the Republicans have 40 Senators during Obama’s first year of total failure. And I hate to tell you this, but the 40 Republicans represent about half the population of the country. Nice try though. Finally, that word "coincidence," it doesn't mean what you think it means. Look it up sometime.
So what have progressives learned? Says Michael Kazin a “history professor” from Georgetown University: “It was always naive to expect a president to start a movement. It’s a little bit like expecting a chief executive to start a union.” Huh? What a horrible analogy. Also, I thought progressives were already a movement? And I thought Obama was one of you, not some random corporate type who you hoped would form a progressive movement? Sounds like Michael could use him some skoolin?
In any event, Bob Borosage of some liberal institute says that progressives need to form a movement like the Tea Party people to “challenge conservative Democrats and Republicans and challenge the White House.” Only then might you see a “bolder agenda.” Why does this sound like sour grapes: “we never really tried yet,” and “Obama wasn’t really a progressive.”
So what do progressives do now to recapture the initiative they never had because they never tried and because Obama was never a true progressive who had to face all those Republicans from little states with so much damn power? According to our friend Eric, they just need to wait for the public to turn against Republicans just in time for Obama’s second term:
Yes, let’s wait for the public to hate the other guys and then they’ll love us! Now that’s solid advice, because we all know that hating one person translates into loving another. Heck, Eric should write a dating column!“This would be consistent with FDR’s strategy during his second term and makes a kind of sense when one considers the nature of the opposition he faces today and the likelihood that it will discredit itself following a takeover of one or both houses in 2010.”
Of course, there is one minor problem with this. If those evil small states can be bought, then how do we “uncorrupt” those states in 2012? And, even worse, if Obama is nothing but a non-progressive CEO, why would he suddenly become one in 2012?
Oh the agony. . .
[+] Read More...
Index:
AndrewPrice,
Barack Obama,
Liberal Thinking,
Liberals
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Americans Want Bipartisanship!!!!!!!!!!!!
I told you the other day that if you want to know what’s really going on, don’t listen to what people tell, but look at their actions. In that regard, I saw the biggest harbinger of a massive Democratic defeat yet: the first article in a very long time warning us that Americans truly desire “bipartisanship.” Uh huh, sure.If you believe the media, than the American public seems strangely schizophrenic. At times, all “the public” wants is bipartisanship and “an end to partisan rancor.” But then at other times, the media tells us “the public” wants the majority party to steamroll the objections of the minority party to put into place the very partisan goals the public apparently wants. How do we reconcile these conflicting opinions? Well, without more facts, this would be virtually impossible. But we have more facts.
Indeed, the key missing fact seems to be which party is in power at the time. When the Republicans control the levers of power, the media pimps the idea that the public wants bipartisanship. . . that the public wants both sides to work together to make sure that the concerns of the minority are heard and that the majority doesn’t put in place a partisan agenda. In fact, if you believe the media, the public is so concerned about “bipartisanship” that they don’t want the Republicans doing anything the Democrats don’t also want. But when the Democrats are in charge, the media suddenly abandons any ideas of bipartisanship and instead sees any efforts by the Republicans to have their voices heard as “obstructionism.” In fact, you see outraged articles that the Democrats aren’t being tough enough with the obstructionist Republicans. Thus, it doesn’t take a genius to see that what is really going on is that the media runs whichever theme is most likely to result in Democratic policies being put into place.
Hence, during the past two years, all the media talked about was obstruction and whether or not it was right for highly partisan Republicans to try to oppose the agenda “the public” wanted. . . polls to the contrary be damned. There were even a series of handwringing articles calling for an end to the evil power of “filibuster” by which a small group of corrupt Senators “representing as little as 1/3 of the population can stand in the way of the public’s desires.” Forget that this theoretical result is practically impossible because places like Rhode Island and Hawaii will never vote the same way as Wyoming. Forget that there were no similar complaints when the Democrats were using it. Forget that this is a check on the power of a majority forcing itself upon the minority. Forget that this doesn’t mean that "nothing can be done," it just means that the majority needs to address the concerns of the minority. Yeah. . . forget all that.
So what does it mean that we now have our first article about the public’s love for bipartisanship since Bush was in office? It means that the writing is on the wall: the Democrats are in serious, serious trouble. It means that the liberal media is laying the groundwork for the switch from anti-obstructionism to pro-obstructionism. Indeed, if I were in the predicting game, I would say that it’s only a matter of time before we start getting articles justifying the noble filibuster, which protects the majority from the overreach of a small, corrupt minority party that somehow temporarily got control over the Congress because of trickery, racism, witchcraft, and evil states like Texas.
But I don’t want to appear cynical. So maybe we should take the media at face value this time? Maybe the public really has suddenly rediscovered a love for bipartisanship? Maybe the public does want drastic bipartisan spending cuts, a bipartisan un-effeteing of our foreign policy, a bipartisan repeal of ObamaCare, a bipartisan financial regulation that actually does something beside pay lip service to progressives yet pander to Wall Street insiders, a bipartisan energy bill that opens more land to drilling, and a bipartisan anti-corruption bill that purges the Obama Administration and the Congress of racists, liars, crooks, sex offenders, nepotism, and perks?
Sure, why not? So in the spirit of bipartisanship, I ask the media to abandon its partisan rancor, and to get onboard. . . stop trying to oppose what the public wants! Seriously, “can’t we all just get along?”
[+] Read More...
Barbara Boxer Thanks The Dept Of Transportation
I originally planned to entitle this post "Hey, Nancy, can I borrow some of your botox?" But I thought better of it. Instead, I decided I should stick to the subject instead of taking the obvious cheap shot. Senator Boxer still hasn't gotten the word that I left the Democratic Party in 1994, and left San Francisco in June of this year, so she keeps sending me her "accomplishments" updates.The language of her latest missive uses the language becoming so common for justifying more government spending: "Last week the U. S. Department of Transportation announced new investments in California mass transit that will create jobs, reduce commute times, and improve air quality." Well, it will create a few more public employee/union jobs. Which of course will mean fare increases, and likely no improvement in service.
"DOT will provide nearly $19 million for four California regional bus services, including more than $6.8 million for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency's Phelan Loop Bus Facility Project." Another greenie-weenie boondoggle. My first question is "where did DOT get the $19 million it is so generously providing the agencies?" The taxpayers, perhaps? And those of you who have read my San Francisco Diary for any length of time know my opinion (and the facts) of the horrendous failure that is MUNI.
"Building the Phelan Loop Bus Facility paves the way for a landscaped open space, new retail space, and new affordable housing--all next to public transportation and within walking distance of both a major transit hub and San Francisco City College." Oh, brother (or sister, as the case may be)! "Paves the way" is another way of saying the City will need more money for a landscaping project which probably will never occur and which is not funded by the "gift" from DOT. San Francisco keeps raising taxes, adding city "inspectors" and increasing payroll taxes doing every possible hostile act toward businesses. Who, exactly, is going to fill this new retail space? Small businesses are beating a hasty retreat to points north, south and east. They'd head west, too, except they'd end up in the ocean.
Ah, and "affordable housing." That's liberal-speak for crappy ticky-tacky housing which will be occupied by people who can't afford the affordable, and so will be getting subsidies from the taxpayers either in the form of direct assistance or higher property taxes on "unaffordable housing" from those rotten rich folks. But at least it will be close to San Francisco City College. That's the junior college for illiterates too dull to get into the big leftist schools like San Francisco State or Berkeley. Their most popular course is "Marx for Dummies."
"The upgraded transit infrastructure will be a key component of a MUNI transit system that is expected to grow from today's 700,000 weekday boardings to more than a million weekday boardings by 2030." Two independent studies have shown that those ridership figures are pure hokum. And like so many Democrat schemes, the plan counts the same riders twice. First, they're counted as future riders on the new system. Then they're counted by routes which are already covered by other transportation lines. Think of it this way. I used to take the 19 bus or the 27 bus to get to work, depending on which one showed up first. I was still only one rider who used two lines. But MUNI and Boxer would count me as two riders if the 19 were a new line while the 27 was the old line.
"I am so pleased that the Department of Transportation has funded this vital project." No, Babs, they took the taxpayers' money in order to mis-spend it again. The DOT has absolutely no "funds" that they didn't first take from us. And now, back to the Democrat spin on another spending (stimulus?) project. "This investment will create jobs in construction, transit, and nearby retail; reduce commute times for both buses and private automobiles; and improve air quality by helping get more people out of their cars and onto an improved transit system."
I plan to keep Boxer in the dark, since she has so far missed my defection from the ranks of the liberal underclass. It will act as a regular reminder of why I finally gave up and left the city that I had loved for so many years. San Franciscans have been hearing this "mass transit/public transportation" garbage for so many years that nobody even listens anymore. First: The new system. Second: The breakdown of the new system. Third: The shocking cost overruns in building then fixing the new system. Fourth: The news that new ridership was only a small proportion of the number predicted. Fifth: The buses start running later and later by the day. Sixth: The buses become filthy, ridership is comprised largely of homeless people, fare-jumpers and the occasional violent thugs. Seventh: MUNI decides the buses can be cleaned up, the dangerous and dirty conditions corrected, and the coaches made to run on time if only the citizens will just vote for another fare increase. Repeat until done.
[+] Read More...
Monday, July 12, 2010
Israelis Dislikes Obama Because They're Bigots
I am going to bet you think that the title means that Israelis are just like white Americans who hate black folks. But you would be wrong. The real reason Israelis have contempt for Barack Obama is that they think he's a Muslim and possibly an Arab. Or so The One apparently thinks. Oh, those silly Israelis.In an interview a few days back, the reporter asked the president why it seems that so many Israelis do not feel all warm and toasty whenever His Messiahship comes up in a discussion. Obama's response (no warning from the TelePrompter) was: "Some of it may be just the fact that my middle name is Hussein, and that creates suspicion." Attorney and blogger J. Christopher Pryor says: "the implications of Obama's statements are truly frightening. By stating that Israelis are suspicious of him because he has a Muslim name, he reveals his belief that the Jews are superficial and racist, and distrust all Muslims."
Of course, Pryor was addressing only one facet of the mind of Obama. He sort of missed the part about how Obama has insulted Israel multiple times, demanded that Israel surrender portions of its national territory (which it has offered to do in past negotiations with the so-called Palestinians), and made it abundantly clear that he would toss Israel to the wolves in the name of world unity. About the only thing he hasn't done is publicly adopt the attitude of his second-hand friend Calypso Louie Farrakhan in discussing the blood-sucking Jews.
Now we all know that our beloved president is a solid Christian who would never let an antisemitic or anti-Israel thought cross his mind. After all, his father taught him tolerance, and his best Christian friends are the great race healers such as Michael Pfleger and Jeremiah Wright. But I digress.
The recent meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu did very little to assuage the impression that Obama would just as soon the Israelis simply disappeared and quit making the president's life difficult. At least this time, Obama didn't treat Netanyahu like a homeless person asking for a handout while he courted world dictators. But it wasn't much better. Netanyahu was gracious about the slights he had been treated to at Obama's hands awhile back, but in interviews after the meeting, he felt he had to make it clear that Israel would defend its existence with or without help from the Waffler-in-Chief in the White House.
Obama has made a habit of exaggerating and publicizing any mistake a low-level Israeli diplomat might make, but never acknowledges the major concessions that Israel has offered in the past for the sake of ending the Intifada and bringing peace to Gaza. Some time back, the Israeli Minister of the Interior announced that Israel might, maybe, could, and would consider building in Ramat Shlomo, a neighborhood in an Israeli territory within the Israeli capital. Obama and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton blew that up into a near international incident, all the while knowing that the statement was contrary to stated Israeli policy. It is clear that Obama not only wants to exacerbate Israeli/Palestinian relations, but feels he is entitled to set internal policy for a sovereign nation.
Add to that Obama's demand that Israel immediately agree to an absolute "total settlement freeze," and you just might have another reason why Israelis would distrust him. But that's irrelevant once you realize that it all really comes down to Israel's bigotry against Muslims, among whom the ignorant Israeli populace includes The One. After all, Obama wouldn't ever match that bigotry, could he? His grandmother was a typical white person, and he instantly recognized and damned the bigotry of a white cop who stupidly arrested a black Harvard professor.
Obama also made fun of people who didn't vote for him because he "doesn't look like the other Presidents." It's obvious Obama doesn't have a bigoted bone in his body, but is instantly capable of recognizing it in others. Particularly those damned Jews. Why would they dislike someone who has spent most of his life adoring his Muslim (and absentee) father, and who has declared America to be "one of the largest Muslim nations?" Clearly, Obama has no particular sympathies for Islam, and his middle name is proof of absolutely nothing. Well, maybe that's not entirely true, but the simple fact is that not one important Israeli spokesperson has ever suggested that they distrusted Obama because he's a "secret Muslim."
More importantly, the Israelis have gone out of their way to condemn nobody solely on the basis of their actual adherence to Islam. Muslims and Arabs are allowed full representation in the Israeli Knesset (Congress). If they aren't carrying bombs (or even large rocks), they are allowed to move about within Israel with only minor inconvenience occasioned by national security. And no Israeli official or any poll taken in Israel has ever indicated an animus toward Obama stemming from his middle name.
Still, if the delusional Obama didn't have Israeli racism to blame for the antipathy many Israelis feel toward him, he might have to admit that maybe they dislike him simply because he's a perfidious ally, a weak sister in a tough world, and a sympathizer with tyrants, dictators, oppressors and human rights violators all over the world, most of whom are neither Muslim nor Arab. Israelis know a self-serving twerp when they see one, and it wouldn't matter if his middle name were Jesus, they would still be very suspicious of Barack Jesus Obama.
[+] Read More...
The Republican Agenda 2010 (AndrewPrice Version)
An announced agenda should be short and easy to understand, and it should consist of concrete policy ideas. It should include only things that will generate both broad public support and intense public interest. It should not be all inclusive, nor should it be littered with esoteric concepts or ideas that appeal only to the base. Those are best dealt with in a larger platform or direct contact.
Here is my take on the best agenda for November 2010:
1. The Fiscal Responsibility Act: As I explained before, and as Admiral Mullen of the Joint Chiefs recently agreed, our deficit has become a national security threat. We must get this under control immediately. To that end, I propose the following spending cuts:
There are other cuts I would add, but these should be the “highlight points.” We should be able to reduce Obama’s $1.6 trillion deficit to $500 billion in the first year without even touching entitlements or defense spending, though I would touch both. . . just not in the agenda. For example, to save Social Security, we need to raise the retirement age to 70 and I would offer people a reduced “buy-in” if they want to get Social Security earlier (something like a 10% permanent reduction for every year earlier they want to start receiving it). Click here for additional details on the spending cuts above.• Cancel The TARP: We should not be using tax money to enrich banks, nor should we allow this pool of money to become a slush fund as the Democrats are trying to use it. At last count, $364 billion remains outstanding.
• Cancel The “Stimulus”: The “stimulus” was classic throwing good money after bad. Much of this can still be avoided.
• Cut Federal Employment & Salaries: During the last decade federal pay far outstripped private pay. We need to force the government to do what the private sector does in recessions: cut 10% of the civilian workforce and cut pay 10% across the board. For political reasons, I would limit the pay cuts to anyone making more than $25,000 a year.
• Non-Defense Discretionary Spending Cut: A 10% cut in spending across the board would be significant yet would not even reduce the budget to the levels it was at under free-spending George Bush -- making this something the government can do with little problem.
2. The Economic Recovery and Revitalization Act: America needs a genuine, long-term stimulus. Years of creeping regulation and taxes have hurt our economy, and now government spending is threatening to wipe it out. And everything both parties have offered for “stimulus” is an economic joke. I propose the following instead:
• Cut Payroll Taxes Across the Board by 2%: As I explained before, such a cut makes working more valuable for workers and it makes employees cheaper for employers, all of which leads to an increased desire to work and an increased demand for workers. By expanding the desire to produce more “work,” we actually stimulate the economy to achieve more, as compared to stimulus spending which merely shifts demand from the future.
• Eliminate Payroll Taxes on the Elderly and Teens: The idea here is to encourage older workers to work longer, to encourage younger workers to start working (and develop beneficial habits), and to encourage employers to bring these people into the workforce. Making non-productive “assets” (e.g. the retired and the young) productive is another way to permanently stimulate the economy. In fact, this is the basis of the various “Asian miracles” -- non-productive peasants and women being brought into the labor force.
• Cut The Capital Gains Tax On Asset Sales: As explained previously, cutting the capital gains tax encourages companies to buy new equipment quicker. This increases demand and makes companies more productive. It also gets older equipment into the used market quicker, helping smaller companies. To counter the idea that this is about stock sales, I would propose limiting this capital gains tax cut to the sale of capital equipment (or eliminating the capital gains on the recapture of depreciation). This would allow the Republicans to paint the Democrats as opposed to workers if they opposed it.
• Reduce the Top Income Bracket: It’s time to flatten the tax bracket. First, I would cut the top bracket by 2% and schedule it for further 2% cuts every two years until it hits 20%. Secondly, I would raise the lowest bracket at the same time until it reaches 20% as well. The idea is to flatten the tax code and to make sure that most Americans pay some tax, I’ve explained the reason for this before. To prevent the charge that this is anti-poor, I would include a $2,500 a year credit, which would NOT be indexed to inflation, meaning its value would fall over the next 10-15 years.
• Energy Independence: Last year, the United States bought $470 billion in imported oil -- about half came from countries that don’t like us. If we opened more land for drilling and invested in the conversion from an oil-based economy to a natural gas-based economy, about half that $470 billion would be spent in places like Arkansas, California and the Dakotas instead of Saudi Arabia. At a minimum, this would add $235 billion flowing through the American economy each year. Additionally, the new supply and competition from gas would drive down the price of oil, which would make food, goods and everything cheaper. Finally, switching to natural gas would dramatically reduce the amount of carbon put into the air. . . if you believe in global warming.
3. The Genuine Health Care Reform Act: The United States health care system is broken. It costs too much and achieves too little, its costs are out of control, not enough people have access to regular care, and it suffers from poor quality control. ObamaCare only makes this worse. Republicans should be pushing CommentaramaCare. But they won’t. So at the very least, they should be promising:
• Repealing and replacing ObamaCare.
• Fully funding Medicare.
• Granting federal licenses to doctors to allow them to work anywhere in the country.
• Opening the insurance market to interstate competition.
• Encouraging a switch to out-of-pocket payment, supplemented by catastrophic care insurance.
• Opening the medical market to new forms of competition by allowing providers to organize freely, just as any other company can, and by allowing them to introduce new pricing models.
• Requiring medical providers to make pricing available prior to treatment.
• Malpractice reform, and improving doctor training and supervision.
4. The Clean and Accountable Government Act: Corruption and abuse of power have become endemic. It’s time to change that:
• TARP/Stimulus Audits: It’s time to bring in independent auditors to examine the TARP, the TALP, and the Stimulus, to determine exactly where the money went, how it was spent, and whether we have been paid back in full.
• Require independent audits of Congress with full release of the results.
• A Perk-Free Congress: It’s time to end the perks that Congress gives itself. No more private planes, no taxpayer-funded alcohol, junkets, parties, vacations, office decorations, etc. There should also be an anti-nepotism act to prevent Congress members from hiring their own family members.
• Tighten the rules on lobbyists to stop the revolving door between big business and government.
• Campaign Finance Reform: It violates the First Amendment to tell people how they can spend their money to support campaigns, but we can (and should) require full disclosure of donations. In particular, we should require corporations to disclose their donations to their shareholders, and unions to disclose their donations to their members. We should also require unions to allow their members to “opt-out” of contributing to the union’s political funds, with a private right of action to enforce this, i.e. civil suits by members.
• Eliminate All Federal Czars: These are unconstitutional, unaccountable positions that are making informal laws that apply only to certain people. This is unacceptable in a democracy.
5. Immigration Reform: Finally, we have immigration reform. This requires its own separate post, but generally the Republicans should stick with the following principles:
As I said before, there are many other things I would want the Republicans to do, but they should not be included in a published agenda. For example, I would look at regulating Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and I would redo the Dodd-Frank financial regulation. But trying to sell this to the public would put people to sleep.• Protecting the border.
• Creating a system that lets employers verify if a prospective employee is legally in the country, and punishing employers who hire illegal aliens.
• Ensuring that guest workers can still be brought in where labor shortages exist.
• Refusing to create “a path to citizenship” for people who are here illegally.
• Taking the burden off of states.
You may also notice an absence of social policy and foreign policy. The reasons for this are simple. Right now, the public is focused almost entirely on issues of economic policy, corruption and abuse of power. Highlighting social issues at this point would not be wise. Similarly, foreign policy is omitted because it doesn’t excite the public and because it remains the zone of control of the President. This is not to say that these issues shouldn’t be addressed, but I would not include them in a public agenda.
[+] Read More...
Saturday, July 10, 2010
The Verdict's In--Let's Riot
Two things happened this past Thursday that were absolutely predictable. A not-too-bright and poorly-trained Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) cop was convicted of involuntary manslaughter in the death of career lawbreaker Oscar Grant. And Grant's supporters rioted (allegedly because they thought the white cop, Johannes Mehserle, should have been convicted of murder in the shooting of black arrestee Grant).I discussed the shooting multiple times in my San Francisco Diary. Mehserle's supporters argued that the shooting was an understandable and forgivable error committed during the heat of a racially-charged and obscenity-laced arrest. They further argued that Mehserle mistook his gun for his taser. Grant's supporters claim the shooting was cold-blooded murder by a racist cop. Mehserle's supporters wanted him to get a free pass in an avoidable death. Grant's supporters wanted nothing less than the death penalty. The jury quite reasonably found Mehserle guilty of involuntary manslaughter. First degree murder with special circumstances was never on the table, so there was never the possibility of the death penalty. But a riot is rarely very logical, and most often an excuse for further lawbreaking.
The options for the jury ranged from second degree murder to involuntary manslaughter, with voluntary manslaughter as another option. I won't plague you with esoteric discussions of the various degrees of homicide, but I will remind you that one of the options not specifically included in the charges was acquittal (complete exoneration). The jury was smart enough to figure out that "oops, I made a mistake" is not a sufficient defense in matters where a deadly weapon was used, even if by accident, by a police officer to kill a defendant who was in custody, fully-restrained, and unable to do any serious harm to the arresting officers. Negligent homicide and involuntary manslaughter are essentially indistinguishable, and after hearing all the evidence, the jury made its decision.
In my earlier posts, I pointed out that Mehserle was the perfect example of why glorified security guards should not suddenly be raised to the level of police officers just to make the security guards feel better about themselves. BART only recently had gotten the legislature to raise the status of their security forces to full-blown police officers. Well--you can call them the Supreme Judiciars for all I care, and it doesn't change the fact that those security guards have neither the training nor the experience of real police officers. Mehserle was a horrific situation waiting to happen.
Let's not forget that criminal matters require proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The jury found reasonable doubt that Mehserle intended to kill Grant, and that meant they could no longer consider second degree murder--a specific intent crime. That left them only with involuntary manslaughter or acquittal. However stupid, negligent or incomprehensible Mehserle's action was, the testimony, including videos from both sides, showed a mystified Mehserle recoiling in horror and confusion after the shooting.
Let's look at another issue. The defense was successful in arguing change of venue based on pretrial publicity. For those who don't know it, the case was removed to Los Angeles. The defense was looking for a fair and impartial jury in a neutral court, not for an acquittal-minded jury. If they had been looking for the latter, they could have found a better venue than the one that found four police officers guilty of violating Rodney King's civil rights after a state jury had cleared them of all criminal charges. The verdict of involuntary manslaughter was not the result of a jury composed largely of white law and order types who were looking to let one of their own get away with the killing of a black man.
And that allows me to segue into the comparisons being made by both sides between this case and the Rodney King case. Yes, there are some similarities. Black arrestee, white cops. But that's about it for the comparisons. Rodney King was not in custody, but was being placed under arrest and violently resisted. Oscar Grant also objected to being arrested, loudly and physically, but he was on the ground in full restraint when the shooting occurred. King was tased and billy-clubbed multiple times (and amazingly kept getting up and advancing on the police officers after being told "stay down, we don't want to hurt you)." Grant was shot in the back.
Under the rules of engagement at the time of the Rodney King arrest, after the police officers ordered him to put his hands in the air and come slowly toward them, the officers were justified in using deadly force when King instead advanced quickly toward them while reaching into the waist band of his pants. Still, the police did not use deadly force, restraining themselves from doing so under orders from their commander who was later one of the officers sent to prison for violating King's civil rights.
Police officers have been much restricted in their rules of engagement with persons who physically resist a lawful arrest since the King case. It isn't based so much on good police work or any kind of solid logic as it is on political correctness and fear of bad press. Oh, and fear of riots. But there's a big difference between tasing a very large man with a violent criminal record who had only recently been released from prison and who is advancing menacingly on the police, and the shooting death of a low-level, rather smallish career lawbreaker who was already fully restrained. The jury was able to figure that out, even if Mehserle's supporters couldn't.
The people who stirred up the crowds in Oakland after the verdict repeatedly used the word "murder" to describe the killing. A jury found otherwise. And it wasn't a Ku Klux Klan jury from the 60s. Among the speakers at the daytime rally claiming murder were the gussied-up and cleaned-up parents of the thug that was killed. They managed to raise a lowlife who was constantly in trouble with the law, but now blame white society for their son's death. Well, a white man did it, not white society. And a racially-mixed jury found him culpable. Justice was served. But the parents need expiation for their own failures, so they wanted revenge, not justice. And a huge portion of the crowd wanted something even simpler. They wanted an excuse to riot.
It was a lame excuse for rioting (I might even have understood a riot, if not approving of it, if the jury had acquitted Mehserle). But after the parents cleaned up their own history as parents, and the white leftists finished making their fine speeches about racial oppression and police brutality, they went home, idiotically sure that the protest had made its point and nothing further would occur.
The rioters fooled them again. As soon as dark began to fall, and the police presence lessened, the thugs and gangsters took over the night. Once again, the political principle of "no justice, no peace" was demonstrated by a romp through the business district resulting in smashed windows, small fires, and the disappearance of wide-screen TVs, jewelry, clothing, along with the entire inventory of expensive running-shoes from the local Foot Locker store.
I predicted the verdict months ago, even before the trial was moved to Los Angeles. I predicted that anything short of a murder conviction would result in riots in Oakland. Now let me give you one more prediction (I'm not as sure of this one, but I'm fairly comfortable with the logic). This riot was nothing like the mayhem that followed the Rodney King case, and not even as bad as the riots that followed the actual shooting of Oscar Grant. But now the case will return to Oakland for the sentencing phase. This will no longer be a long-distance pronouncement from the court. The judge must weigh facts in aggravation and facts in mitigation to come up with a sentence. And no matter how much he may find all aggravation and no mitigation (a very unlikely result), the California provision for involuntary manslaughter with no prior record is two to four years in state prison.
If the judge imposes the maximum penalty, it will still not be nearly enough for the rioters-in-waiting. By nightfall on the day of the sentencing, Oakland (and probably a few other Bay Area communities) will be under siege. And that won't be the end of it. Lawlessness doesn't exist solely on the mean streets of Oakland. It exists at the very highest levels of government.
If the Rodney King case proved nothing else, it proved that rioting is an effective way of nullifying jury verdicts and spurring the cowards and race-baiters into high gear. In the Grant case, the mere threat of riots has spurred the Justice Department into "looking into the matter." Mehserle hasn't even been sentenced yet, and still the same Department that dismissed all the New Black Panther voter-intimidation cases is considering how it can slap both the jury and the judge in the face for not drawing and quartering Mehserle. State verdicts be damned. The feds are on the case!
As so often happens, what seems to be perfectly legitimate legislation can be perverted into another excuse for the national government to usurp the power of the states. The law under which the Rodney King police officers were convicted, and which Mehserle is likely to face, was designed for very different times and very different situations. The civil rights concurrent federal jurisdiction laws were written originally and justifiably to overcome the effects of Ku Klux Klan and white supremacist murders in the South that went unpunished by all-white local juries. In order to avoid the double-jeopardy provisions of the Constitution, the prosecutions were for an entirely different class of crimes. You got away with murder, boys, but you're not going to escape serious federal prison time for the ultimate method of violating a black person's civil rights. You didn't get the death penalty that you so richly deserved, but we're going to send you to prison for most of the rest of your lives as a substitute.
On the plus side, racial relations were improving dramatically over the decades since the Ku Klux Klan cases. Southern juries are no longer all-white, and murderers are routinely convicted by local juries regardless of race. So in order to justify their existence, Justice Department political lawyers have taken those statutes and turned them into a bludgeon to beat down the police no matter how egregious the behavior of the black defendant. Eric Holder's Justice Department is now likely to carry the King case one step further by finding that a conviction is not enough, we need a really tough sentence as well. Racial relations have gone backwards under Barack Obama's stewardship, and this pandering to the lawless will set relations back even more.
The Ku Klux Klan cases, and the subsequent Rodney King case proved the old legal adage: Hard cases make bad law. It also proved that there's nothing like a good healthy riot to motivate the fearful and cowardly into perverting the rule of law to obtain a result more in keeping with the wishes of the mob.
[+] Read More...
Friday, July 9, 2010
Evil Is Boring--So We Should Just Ignore It
I just finished reading a book by Terry Eagleton entitled On Evil. Since I have a personal dislike for the trendy concept that there is no such thing as evil, but only "sick" people who should not be punished for their illness, I decided to buy the book. By the time I finished it, I couldn't be sure which side of the debate Eagleton was on. I suggest you wait until it hits the discount table before considering a purchase of the book.Eagleton has, in past tomes, written extensively on his belief that evil is a real thing. He spent much of his research and exposition proving it by pointing to Hitler, Mussolini, and various other fascist tyrants. What was always missing from his analyses was an equal condemnation of evil as demonstrated by Mao, Stalin and Castro. In case you hadn't guessed by now, Eagleton views everything from the Marxist point of view. But On Evil travels a very circuitous road. The best way I can describe it is that despite his earlier expositions proving the existence of evil, he has now written a book about evil for the purpose of proving it doesn't exist. Or it does exist, but it's not very important. Or something.
I remember one of my pastors saying that Satan is the great liar, and the greatest lie he tells is that he doesn't exist. A great many of us believe that he is both the creator and master of evil. On the other hand, most of us don't really picture Satan or evil in the way the accompanying illustration does. For one thing, it makes him too easy to pick out in a crowd. Eagleton says in this recent publication that evil (which must exist if it has characteristics) is boring, supremely pointless, philistine, kitsch-ridden, and superficial. The concept of evil he describes says that people can do unbelievably cruel, vicious, or neglectful things, but evil itself is not worth worrying about, if it even exists.
Eagleton can neither be described as intellectually rigorous nor consistent in the development of his view of evil (or something like it). It seems that he is unintentionally of two minds on almost everything he has written, and spends much of his time refuting his own theories. When in "evil doesn't exist" mode, he has a bad habit of closing his books with Marxist comments on the inevitability of history and class struggle. But only when the mass murderer is not a communist does he find evil in the acts committed.
The problem for Eagleton is that as a Marxist, he cannot adequately describe evil because it's a nearly impossible topic to discuss when there's no God in the analysis. But as much as he wants to eliminate theology from his equation, the religion he rejected as a youth seems to color his descriptions of evil acts committed without underlying evil itself. Then Eagleton will wander off into discussions of the banality of evil but without either the force or theology behind Hannah Arendt who coined the phrase "banality of evil" in her book Eichmann in Jerusalem.
In earlier works, Eagleton found good evil (don't ask me how you reconcile those two words) to be anything but banal. He frequently brings up Thomas Mann's Doktor Faustus in order to discuss his favorite character in the work. Though Eagleton won't admit to admiration, he dotes on Adrian Leverkuhn, whom Eagleton describes as "a Dionysian artist, plumbing the depths of human wretchedness in order to pluck order from chaos. His art strives to wrest the spirit from the flesh, wholeness from affliction, the angelic from the demonic." Huh? Beside his dance with the devil, Leverkuhn went so far as to purposely contract syphilis from a prostitute in order to enhance his musical genius. Well, that definitely isn't banal.
Eagleton admires that kind evil (if that's what it is, depending on the day of the week). He posits that this kind of evil is so outrageous and so defiant of the mores of civilized human beings as to rise to the level of the sublime. In addition, Eagleton slams the narrator of the book for being too decent, too reasonable, and too civilized to appreciate the monstrosity he will face. Leverkuhn, on the other hand, is to be admired for his welcoming of death resulting from his debauched ways.
So at least some of the time, Eagleton admits there is such a thing as evil, but it's only worth considering when it's really grand and destructive evil. The evil inherent in Nazism and communism can be either dreary or purposeful. The former bores him to death, the latter excites him so he has to justify it. Thus, Nazi evil was, well, evil because it lacked legitimate purpose. Communism, particularly as practiced by Mao and Stalin, may or may not have been evil, but in Eagleton's mind it had purpose, and therefore was either forgivable or understandable. Communism served the purpose of freeing people from the tyranny of capitalism. Nazism, on the other hand, served no purpose. The Holocaust was "an orgy of extermination apparently for the hell of it."
Peasants and serfs in Russia and China were murdered by the millions all for the ultimate good of the working class. The Jews were exterminated by Hitler just because they happened to be there. Making Germany free of the "degenerate subhuman Jews" as a palpable purpose doesn't even seem to occur to Eagleton. If it had, he would actually understand the true nature of evil, but it would require him to admit that extermination of a people because of their religion and ethnic makeup is not really much different from doing the same thing by murdering large numbers of people based solely on their unfortunate membership is a certain social stratum.
There is another inconsistency in Eagleton's view of evil as banal. He seemed to get what Arendt was talking about when discussing Eichmann. But he is unable to see that the evil of Eichmann's banal and bureaucratic carrying out of orders was quite different from Hitler's mad fury and hatred of the Jews. If Eagleton had the intellectual consistency necessary to be convincing, he would have put Hitler into the same category as Leverkuhn. Even black racist Louis Farrakhan was able to come up with words describing Hitler as an evil genius (though his shared hatred of Jews also played a part in his assessment).
Where Eagleton is consistent he badly damages his own arguments. By refusing to recognize Hitler as the grandiose type of evildoer that he so admires in Leverkuhn, and ascribing that characteristic to Mao and Stalin instead, he shows his Marxist intellectual intransigence and laziness. And unlike Arendt, Eagleton doesn't recognize that evil can be banal, or it can be wildly dramatic, but either way it's evil. And I would simply add, it's also an offense against God. Eagleton is guilty of combining psychological jargon in seeing evil as a mental disease and Marxist theory in seeing evil as an uncontrollable reaction to economic oppression.
I agree with Alan Wolfe of Yale's final assessment of Eagleton's new book: "None of this makes sense, says Eagleton, but that's how it is with evil. The less sense it makes, the more evil it is. Eagleton's book makes no sense, but it's not evil, it just makes no sense."
[+] Read More...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

